causal

Lockdowns work; their failure in the US was non-compliance

Lockdowns do work for respiratory viruses if people actually stop co-mingling, as demonstrated by Australia and New Zealand's minimal excess mortality; the US 'failure' was due to non-compliance, and the claim that 'lockdowns don't work' usually conflates the finding that stay-at-home orders add little once schools and businesses are already closed—which is itself a functional lockdown.

causalpending

Speaker

Nicholas Christakis

Evidence Quote

“people some people say lockdowns are ineffective but what they mean by that is that the studies show that after you have closed the schools and closed the stores then ordering people to stay home is no longer additionally effective but but basically you've you've functionally implemented a lockdown anyway”

Source

270 - What Have We Learned From The Pandemic— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:55:54 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...