exaggerated realism
Medieval position holding that universal forms exist both transcendently and in particulars, with individuals differing only by degree of privation from the universal form
As defined in A History of Philosophy | 23 Problem of Universals
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “exaggerated realism” →
- Extreme or exaggerated realism, ascribed to John Scotus Eriugena and sometimes to Anselm, holds that forms of species and genera exist in reality separately from particulars while each particular participates in that one and the same form, and these forms exist both transcendently and in particulars such that there is a numerically identical form recurring in every particular case. Individuals are differentiated only by their degree of privation—their degree of non-participation in the full form.A History of Philosophy | 23 Problem of Universals
- William of Champeaux initially advocated exaggerated realism but came under criticism from Roscelin and Abelard, causing him to retreat to a position known as indifferentism, in which forms exist only in the reality of particulars (not in a transcendent sense), with all members of a species indifferently participating in that one and the same form.A History of Philosophy | 23 Problem of Universals
- Exaggerated realism was given theological application to defend Christian doctrines: the Trinity (three personal subsistences within the essence of one godhead through participation in a universal form), the universal Church (particular individuals participating in a universal), Original Sin (as a universal evidenced in all particular cases), and Transubstantiation (particular accidents remain the same while the essence changes from bread to body and wine to blood).A History of Philosophy | 23 Problem of Universals