evolutionary mismatch
The hypothesis that mental templates evolved for ancestral conditions (e.g., small-band leadership selection) are poorly suited to the very different modern environment our societies have rapidly created.
As defined in 189 | Brian Klaas on Power and the Temptation of Corruption
Where it comes up · 7
- 248 - Order Freedom2 claims
- Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - David Reich – Why the Bronze Age was an inflection point in human evolution1 claim
- Michael Easter on Excess, Moderation, and the Scarcity Brain1 claim
- 128 - Transformations Of Mind1 claim
- 102 - Is Buddhism True1 claim
- 109 - Biology And Culture1 claim
- 189 | Brian Klaas on Power and the Temptation of Corruption1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “evolutionary mismatch” →
- Evolution does not prepare creatures to fit their current environments; it prepares them to fit the environments of their ancestors, and only appears to fit current environments because those usually resemble ancestral ones. Mismatch occurs when an environment looks nothing like the ancestral one—this is why biblical sanitation rules were better than nothing in their time but must now be replaced by the mechanistic germ theory of disease; the difficulty is knowing which inherited beliefs are safe to jettison, which are now dangerous, and which still serve hidden purposes.109 - Biology And Culture
- Across 57 countries, loose cultures fared dramatically worse with COVID—roughly five times the cases per capita and nearly nine times the deaths, controlling for wealth, inequality, age, density, and climate—because evolutionary game theory models showed loose groups take significantly longer to cooperate under threat, and survey data showed people in loose cultures remained far less fearful of COVID (about 50% very scared vs 70% in tight cultures), demonstrating an evolutionary mismatch where looseness, adaptive for innovation, is maladaptive against abstract collective threat.248 - Order Freedom
- COVID created an evolutionary mismatch: conservatives are normally more threat-sensitive (shown in surveys, experiments, and neuroscience), but because the virus is invisible, abstract, and easy to ignore—unlike warfare or terrorism—combined with leaders telling them not to worry, conservatives' usual threat-sensitivity was hijacked and distorted, causing them to resist tightening (e.g., mask wearing) rather than embrace it.248 - Order Freedom
- Because the evolution of our brains has not kept pace with the rapid transformation of our societies, the mental templates we use to select leaders may have been adaptive for ancestral small-band life but are mismatched to modern hierarchical societies — though this evolutionary-mismatch hypothesis is unfalsifiable and should be held with skepticism.189 | Brian Klaas on Power and the Temptation of Corruption
- Natural selection has not been constant across time and place: comparing the last 5,000 years (Bronze Age onward) to the previous 5,000 years shows that the intensification of selection around immune and metabolic traits accelerated, consistent with the population reacting to a dramatic shock—much higher densities, living next to animals and exchanging diseases—that created an evolutionary mismatch for a population descended from hunter-gatherers only 10,000 years earlier.Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - David Reich – Why the Bronze Age was an inflection point in human evolution
- The scarcity brain—the feeling that we can't get enough—exists because in our ancestral environments of scarcity, leaning into more (food, possessions, information, status) conferred a survival advantage, creating an evolutionary mismatch now that we live in abundance.Michael Easter on Excess, Moderation, and the Scarcity Brain
- Feelings can be useful to the organism, useful only from natural selection's gene-propagation standpoint, or useless from anyone's standpoint in a modern environment; status-seeking, public-speaking anxiety, and daycare-drop-off anxiety often produce suffering and illusions (catastrophe scenarios) that served gene propagation in ancestral environments but help no one now, so meditators benefit from observing such feelings as transient phenomena rather than investing them with meaning.102 - Is Buddhism True
- Human emotions—fear, anger, love, loss, jealousy, shame, guilt—are not simple or basic but finely tuned complex adaptive systems that each solve particular problems, and they can be flexibly repurposed and connected to cognition in modern contexts, as when anger is channeled into moralistic outrage over an abstract logical error; widespread depression and anxiety in the young reflect a mismatch between these ancient emotional repertoires and weird aspects of modern life.128 - Transformations Of Mind