What this covers

David Reich uses new large-scale ancient DNA data and a novel relatedness-based method to argue that natural selection in humans did not plateau after the agricultural revolution but instead accelerated sharply during the Bronze Age, when the move into dense settlements created a biological shock. The conversation traces his evidence across immune, metabolic, pigmentation, and cognitive-predictor traits—showing that selection intensified between 5,000 and 2,000 years ago more dramatically than during the initial Neolithic transition 10,000 years earlier. Reich also presents a heterodox model of human origins: that Neanderthals were not a wholly separate lineage but rather a genetically-swamped population of culturally-modern humans who interbred with local archaics in Europe, retaining some modern genetic markers (mitochondrial DNA and Y chromosome) alongside a predominantly archaic nuclear genome.

The scope spans human evolutionary biology, ancient genetics, and deep history. Reich discusses why time-limited vs population-limited selection matters more than population size above a modest threshold, how wave-of-advance genetic swamping explains population mixture during expansions, and why the long fuse delay—the 40,000-to-60,000-year gap between acquiring the cognitive toolkit for agriculture and actually practicing it—points to climate stability rather than genetics as the trigger for farming's origins. He addresses the 2016 Swapan Mallick study showing no fixed genetic differences across the cognitive revolution, examines the incompatibility scales as square of divergence principle to explain varying levels of genetic mixing, and details how introgression of weak ancestry signals can still mark major cultural transmission. The cognitive selection findings are contentious—showing upward movement in polygenic predictors of intelligence over 10,000 years—as is the heretical Neanderthal model, which departs sharply from field consensus.

Sharpest takeaway

Reich argues that natural selection in humans has not been quiescent since the agricultural revolution but actually accelerated, peaking during the Bronze Age (~5,000-2,000 years ago) when the move into dense agricultural life wrenched human biology, and he further proposes a heretical model in which Neanderthals are essentially genetically-swamped culturally-modern humans rather than a wholly separate archaic lineage.

  • New large-scale ancient DNA (10,000+ new individuals) plus a novel relatedness-based method reveals hundreds to thousands of genomic positions under directional selection, with selection intensifying in the Bronze Age across immune, metabolic, pigmentation and cognitive-predictor traits.
  • Selection is limited by time, not population size, above a modest population threshold, so the Bronze Age's special status reflects environmental wrenching rather than larger populations.
  • The Neanderthal model: a Middle Stone Age-inventing population expanded from the Caucasus/Middle East, was ~95% genetically swamped by local archaics in Europe (forming Neanderthals) and ~20% swamped by more-diverged archaics in Africa (forming us), explaining shared mtDNA, Y chromosome and toolkit.

The claims · ranked49 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.59

Because the typical time to the common ancestor of any two human gene copies is one to two million years—older than the ~700,000-800,000-year split from Neanderthals and Denisovans—there are many places in a person's DNA where they are more closely related to a Neanderthal than to their own father, just as siblings are more related at some loci and less at others depending on which ancestral DNA they inherited.

factualestablishednovelty 4/4durability 4/4· David Reich

“The average time to the common ancestor of any two human genes is one or two million years ago... So there are many places in your DNA where you're more closely related to a Neanderthal on your mother's side than you are to your father.”

0.57

Simulations and studies of mammals and birds show that when one group expands into territory occupied by another, even a small amount of interbreeding at the moving wave front leads to massive introgression of local genes, because pioneers occasionally interbreed with the locals who vastly outnumber them, so by the time the expanding population reaches the far side it is largely local—explaining how Neanderthals could end up ~95% local archaic yet retain expanding-population culture.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· David Reich

“even if there's a small amount of interbreeding... there's massive introgression of local genes. The pioneers at the wave front will sometimes interbreed with the local population... so by the time they make it to the other side, they're largely local.”

0.55

Natural selection has not been constant across time and place: comparing the last 5,000 years (Bronze Age onward) to the previous 5,000 years shows that the intensification of selection around immune and metabolic traits accelerated, consistent with the population reacting to a dramatic shock—much higher densities, living next to animals and exchanging diseases—that created an evolutionary mismatch for a population descended from hunter-gatherers only 10,000 years earlier.

causalcontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“this intensification of selection around immune traits, and similarly the intensification around metabolic traits, has accelerated over this time period.”

0.55

Counterintuitively, the biological readout shows the genome reacting much more strongly to events ~5,000-4,000 years ago (Bronze Age intensification) than to the initial Neolithic transition to growing plants ~10,000-12,000 years ago, suggesting the move into dense Bronze Age life was a qualitatively greater wrenching of human biology than the first adoption of farming.

factualcontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“the intensification happens 5,000 years ago, 4,000 years ago... the biological readout is saying our genome is reacting much more strongly to these events that happened 5,000 years ago.”

0.55

Anatomically modern humans (and recognizable Neanderthals) appear ~300,000-400,000 years ago at the same moment as the Middle Stone Age, but for ~200,000 years they made Levallois tools and were no more impressive than Neanderthals; behavioral modernity—the quickening of art and innovation—only appears 50,000-100,000 years ago, so there is a long disconnect between the emergence of modern skeletal form and modern behavior whose cause (genetic or cultural) is unknown.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“There is this disconnect between anatomically modern humans in the skeletal record and behaviorally modern humans, which is 50,000 to 100,000 years ago.”

0.55

A 2014 study of ~20,000-30,000 African American genomes (about 80% West African, 20% European ancestry) found no genome locations with significantly more or less than the expected 80% West African ancestry, meaning no detectable natural selection over ~5 generations of intense environmental change—likely because the time period is too short: even a 2% per-generation selection coefficient compounds to only ~10% over five generations.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“We didn't see any place in the DNA that was significantly different from what you would expect by chance. One possible explanation is just that there's only a handful of generations, maybe five”

0.55

The 2016 Mallick et al. study found no fixed differences and no selective sweeps shared among all living humans more recent than ~400,000-500,000 years ago—including across the 100,000-50,000-year cognitive revolution when art and rapid tool innovation appear—implying that any biological adaptation in that critical period was polygenic rather than a single key gene sweeping to high frequency, and possibly that the relevant cultural changes had no genetic basis.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“right across all the DNA we could look at, we couldn't find anything more recent than four or five hundred thousand years ago.”

0.55

The cognitive and behavioral toolkit for farming and state societies was in place in the common ancestral population by ~70,000 years ago (or arguably 200,000-300,000 years ago including Neanderthals), yet there was a 'very long fuse'—a 40,000-60,000-year delay—before these capabilities ignited into agriculture independently across West Africa, the Americas, Europe, East Asia and New Guinea, demonstrated by metal-free, wheel-free, animal-free achievements like Teotihuacán matching ancient Egypt.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“The cognitive resources for doing this must have all been in place, but it's a very long fuse. It delays for 40,000 or 60,000 years in all these different places after the common ancestral population splits up, and then ignites into agriculture”

0.55

The 5% interbreeding signal should not be dismissed, because admixture proportions act as a tracer dye for culture: Yamnaya steppe ancestry, diluted to only 10%, 5% or even 2% in some South Asian groups via Corded Ware expansion through Central Asia and the Hindu Kush, nonetheless tracks Indo-European languages and important shared cultural elements—so a small genetic fraction can mark the transmission of something culturally major.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“it is the tracer dye. It tracks Indo-European languages, and important aspects of Indo-European culture are coming through Yamnaya... this 5%, you shouldn't sneeze at it.”

0.55

The breakthrough rested on two innovations: scaling the data ~14-fold (reporting ~10,000 new ancient individuals for a total dataset of ~16,000 ancient plus modern people) and a new relatedness-based method—borrowed from disease-risk medical studies—that predicts each individual's genotype at 10 million positions from their relatedness to all 22,000 people, then tests whether assuming a constant directional selection rate explains the data better than relatedness alone.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“we just pumped a lot of data into the system, increasing the amount of data by about 14-fold. The main thing that we do in this study is report new data from about 10,000 individuals.”

0.54

The genetic predictor of cognitive performance (and the correlated predictors of years of schooling and household wealth) moved systematically upward by roughly one standard deviation on the scale of modern variation over the last 10,000 years within ancestry-corrected populations, with the selection strongest 2,000-4,000 years ago (about two standard-deviation strength) and essentially zero in the last 2,000 years.

factualcontestednovelty 4/4durability 2/4· David Reich

“there is a strong movement in a systematic direction, a large effect, about a standard deviation on the scale of modern variation.”

0.54

Although whole-genome data place Neanderthals and Denisovans as sisters from a common archaic ancestor (~500,000-600,000 years ago, splitting ~700,000-800,000 years ago from modern humans), Neanderthal mitochondrial DNA and Y chromosome cluster with modern humans and date to only 300,000-450,000 years, having been introduced by a modern-human interbreeding event ~200,000-300,000 years ago that then rose to 100% frequency—an improbable joint event (roughly 5% x 5%) that the field accepts but that is surprising on first principles.

factualestablishednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“if you look at the mitochondrial DNA... Neanderthals and modern humans cluster... it's only 300,000 to 450,000 years.”

0.53

Above a modest population threshold (around a million, well before the Bronze Age), selection's dominant constraint is elapsed time rather than population size: strong selection coefficients of ~0.5-1% per generation work effectively even in populations of 1,000-10,000 because they exceed the drift noise of ~1/N, while only extremely weak coefficients (~1/10,000 or 1/100,000) require large populations and would take hundreds of thousands to millions of years to act—too slow to matter on these timescales.

factualcontestednovelty 4/4durability 4/4· David Reich

“We're talking about strong, measurable selection coefficients on the order of half a percent or more in this study. All of those are going to work in small populations or large populations. It's not going to be affected by the population size.”

0.53

Genetic incompatibilities between diverging populations develop rapidly—probably as the square of the separation time, because they require interacting pairs of genes—so a 1.2-million-year divergence (modern lineage vs archaic Africans) produces far more reproductive barriers than a ~400,000-year divergence (vs Eurasian archaics/Denisovan ancestors), explaining ~20% versus ~95% swamping, while populations only ~70,000-200,000 years apart (West Africans/Europeans, Khoisan/Bantu) are essentially fully interfertile.

causalestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· David Reich

“As populations become further apart, biological incompatibilities rapidly develop, probably as the square of the separation distance, because you need pairs of interacting genes.”

0.53

The human population contains a tremendous amount of standing genetic variation for complex (polygenic) traits—enough that pushing all height variants one way would make a person as tall as a building—so for traits underpinned by many mutations, the variation needed to move a population to a new adaptive set point within hundreds or thousands of years already exists, and the population is no longer mutation-limited as it was when small.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· David Reich

“For complex traits, ones underpinned by many mutations, all the variation already exists to move the population to a different adaptive set point that's optimal in the environment it's in.”

0.53

With eight billion people and ~30 new mutations per person per generation (~240 billion new point mutations per generation against only three billion genome bases), every possible mutation arises about 100 times each generation, so large populations are not mutation-limited—whereas a small population of ~10,000 might wait dozens or hundreds of generations for a key single mutation like lactase persistence to arise.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· David Reich

“There are maybe 30 new mutations every generation, so that's 240 billion new point mutations every generation. There are only three billion DNA bases in the genome, so every mutation that can occur does occur about 100 times every generation.”

0.52

Times of migration and population admixture produce huge whole-genome frequency fluctuations because the incoming groups evolved separately for thousands of years, making these the worst moments to detect natural selection; the best moments are stable periods of a few hundred years within isolated 'archipelago' sub-populations where a single locus can be seen drifting consistently in one direction against the rest of the genome.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“what happens at these times of migration is there are just huge fluctuations in frequencies. These are extremely uninformative times for detecting natural selection.”

0.50

Despite humans being genetically capable of farming for 50,000+ years and distributed worldwide, agriculture independently arose in multiple regions only in the last ~12,000 years (the Holocene), which climate scientists say is uniquely stable on a two-million-year scale—pond-sediment isotope records show far less year-to-year, decadal and centennial temperature fluctuation—suggesting climate stability, not genetics, was the trigger for independent agricultural origins.

causalcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“12,000 years ago we switched into this period of not just warmth, but climate stability... we're in a period where it's fluctuating a lot less year to year, 10 years to 10 years, and 100 years to 100 years.”

0.50

Among the most confidently selected positions, there is a roughly four-to-five-fold enrichment for immune/autoimmune traits and a strong enrichment for metabolic traits (obesity, fat, Type 2 diabetes), but almost no detectable enrichment for behavioral or psychiatric traits—not because behavior is unselected, but because behavioral traits are governed by very large numbers of genes of weak effect that the strong-signal scan lacks power to detect.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“there was a vast enrichment, by about four or five-fold, for immune traits.”

0.50

There has been roughly one standard deviation of selection over the last 10,000 years against the genetic variants conferring obesity, high fat mass, high waist-to-hip ratio and Type 2 diabetes risk, consistent with the thrifty gene hypothesis: moving from hunter-gatherer life into farming with more constant food removed the need to build body fat, so Europeans are now relatively better protected genetically against Type 2 diabetes than groups with less agricultural exposure like African Americans and Native Americans.

causalcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“There is clear selection, by about a standard deviation on the scale of modern variation for these traits, reducing over the last 10,000 years in this part of the world.”

0.49

Reich's heretical model proposes that a population inventing Middle Stone Age / Levallois technology ~300,000-400,000 years ago (around the Caucasus/Northeast Africa) expanded outward; the branch entering Europe interbred with local archaic humans and got ~95% genetically swamped, becoming Neanderthals that retained modern-human culture, mtDNA and Y chromosome, while the branch entering Africa met much more diverged archaic Africans (~1.5 million years separated) and was only ~20% swamped, becoming us—so Neanderthals and modern humans share cultural ancestry and differ only in which archaic humans they later mixed with.

factualfringenovelty 4/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“there is a population here that invents the Middle Stone Age and the Middle Paleolithic, sometimes called Levallois technology, and that people from this population expand into Europe and mix with the local archaic humans who are there. That is what this 5% interbreeding event is.”

0.49

Over its first ~16-17 years, the ancient DNA field succeeded at revealing human history—surprising migrations, frequent mixture, sex-biased processes—but largely failed at its original dream of revealing biological change over time, mainly because sample sizes were too small: a single genome positions an individual exquisitely in history (it represents tens of thousands of ancestors) but gives only one or two samples of any particular variant's frequency.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“The field has been a big success with regard to learning about human history... but what's not been successful is learning about biology and biological change.”

0.49

Rather than being quiescent, natural selection is everywhere in the genome: about 7,200 positions reach 50% confidence of being under selection (roughly half real), tens of thousands more appear at the 25% cutoff, and almost every position is correlated to another being dragged by selection—selection is tugging positions in one direction or another across essentially the whole genome.

factualcontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“multiple analyses we do suggest that the genome is vibrating with natural selection.”

0.49

A 300,000-400,000-year-old site in Spain, Sima de los Huesos, yields hominins with a Neanderthal-like nuclear genome but Denisovan-like mitochondrial DNA and Y chromosome, which looks exactly like a population related to modern humans pushing into a Sima-like archaic population and displacing its uniparental markers while keeping the rest of the genome—direct fossil-genomic support for the swamping model.

factualcontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“They have a nuclear genome that looks Neanderthal-like for most of the genome, but their mitochondrial DNA and Y chromosome are Denisovan-like.”

0.49

To verify the schooling-predictor selection signal was real, Reich's team correlated the effect sizes of variants on years of schooling measured in Chinese people in China against the 10,000-year trajectory of those same variants in Europeans—two essentially disconnected populations—and found a five-to-six standard deviation correlation, as strong as the within-European correlation, which they could not explain by chance and which convinced them the selection signal is genuine.

factualcontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“there's actually a huge statistical correlation, a five or six standard deviation correlation between the effect size of variants on the number of years of school in China today and the trajectory in Europe.”

0.49

Multiple studies of modern (mostly African) DNA show that anatomically modern humans are themselves a mixture of two groups that diverged ~1.5 million years ago and came together ~200,000-300,000 years ago, with roughly 20% ancestry from a deeply-diverged archaic African group and 80% from an early modern lineage—paralleling the Neanderthal mixture (5% modern / 95% local) and reflected across Khoisan and rainforest hunter-gatherer groups in differing proportions.

factualcontestednovelty 4/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“modern humans are a mixture of two groups that diverged maybe 1.5 million years ago, and they come together 200,000 to 300,000 years ago with maybe 20% ancestry from this archaic African group and 80% ancestry from this early modern lineage.”

0.48

A key enabling technique was in-solution enrichment: ancient samples are mostly microbial (often <1-10% human DNA, the rest bacteria and fungi colonizing the body after death), so the DNA is washed over an artificially synthesized set of probes targeting more than a million informative, biologically interesting positions, capturing the human-relevant fraction and turning prohibitively expensive brute-force sequencing into an economical, industrializable process generating thousands of samples per year.

factualestablishednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“We took these samples and washed them over an artificially synthesized set of short DNA fragments that targeted positions of the DNA that we were interested in analyzing.”

0.45

Reich's results run opposite to the collective intelligence hypothesis—the idea that increasing specialization let each person know less and so selected intelligence downward; instead the genetic predictor of cognitive performance was pushed upward most strongly at the dawn of complex societies (Bronze Age) and showed no selection in the last 2,000 years, contrary to the intuition that hunter-gatherers faced higher cognitive demands.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· David Reich

“Your results seem to point in the opposite direction... at least when society began, there was more need for the kind of thing that predicts intelligence today.”

0.45

A 2017 Icelandic study found an estimated 0.1 standard deviation decrease in the genetic predictor of years of schooling within just one century—a huge, fast effect representing selection against the schooling predictor—possibly because the predictor is strongly correlated with the age women have their first child, so it may be measuring reproductive timing rather than intelligence per se.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· David Reich

“There's an estimated 0.1 standard deviation decrease in the genetic predictor of intelligence in Iceland just within one century. It's an absolutely huge effect over a short period.”

0.44

The frequency-difference approach to detecting selection appeared to hit a disappointing asymptote: the 2015 Mathieson et al. study of ~200 ancient Europeans found only 12 significant positions, and despite far better data, a 2024 Copenhagen study found only 21—suggesting either that the method had plateaued or that selection really was quiescent, until the new study's innovations broke through.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· David Reich

“the largest study of that type in 2024 by a group in Copenhagen analyzed much better data than we had in 2015 and found only 21 positions that were highly different in frequency across time.”

0.43

The strength of Ali Akbari's methodology is that it measures selection within an 'archipelago' of small populations localized in space and time (e.g. Britain 4,000-3,500 years ago, Italy 2,000-1,500 years ago), watching whether genetic changes blow in the same direction in each pocket where ancestry is relatively stable, thereby correcting for the large migration-driven ancestry shifts that otherwise swamp the signal.

definitioncontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“The whole strength of the methodology Ali Akbari developed is that it corrects for that changing ancestry over time.”

0.43

Reich's team validated their ~479 highly-confident (and ~3,800 50%-confident) selection signals using a completely independent dataset—the UK Biobank GWAS corpus of ~500,000 people—by showing that as their selection statistic increases, the enrichment for trait-affecting mutations rises from a baseline 15% up to a ~five-fold plateau (~60-70%) above a statistic value of about five, calibrating the probability each position is genuinely selected, and they ruled out background selection as a confound by repeating the analysis within slices matched for background selection and allele frequency.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“when we required the selection statistic to be above about five, there was about a five-fold enrichment for mutations that cause traits.”

0.43

Of all the changes in mutation frequencies observed across ~10 million variable genome positions, only about 2% is due to directional (adaptive) selection while ~98% is other factors—overwhelmingly genetic drift, migration and population structure—which is why adaptive selection signals are extremely hard to detect even though they are pervasive.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“And 98% of it is other factors, especially genetic drift. It's overwhelmingly migrations and population structure causing fluctuations in frequency.”

0.43

The TYK2 genetic variant, a major risk factor for severe tuberculosis, rose under selection to ~9-10% frequency from 8,000-6,000 years ago and then fell sharply under selection over the last 3,000 years—a documented reversal of selection direction plausibly tied to tuberculosis becoming endemic around 2,000-3,000 years ago, with the variant perhaps protective against a different disease beforehand.

causalcontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“this variant rockets up in frequency from 8,000 or 6,000 years ago to maybe 9% or 10% in this part of the world. Then it rockets down in frequency in the last 3,000 years.”

0.42

Several diet-related variants show Bronze Age selection: lactase persistence (adult milk digestion) intensified when cattle began being used for secondary products like milk and wool, and the FADS1/2 variant—a vegetarian/meat-eating adaptation that converts plant fatty acids into long-chain fatty acids and is ancient enough to appear in archaic humans—was under especially high selection ~5,000-3,000 years ago.

causalestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“why do we see lactase persistence, where adults can process milk, intensified during this period? This is the time when we start using cattle not just for the meat, but also for milk”

0.42

Reich describes a recurring, almost traumatic pattern in his career of entering projects with a confident prior that the data then overturns—most notably his prior belief, shared with colleagues, that non-Africans were a simple subset of African variation with no Neanderthal interbreeding, which he spent years trying to make go away before the strong Neanderthal-into-non-African signal only got stronger; the same happened with the selection study.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“I've come into a project with some kind of guess about what the data was showing, and then the data doesn't show that.”

0.42

Europeans got lighter skin over the last 10,000 years, and depigmentation—the strongest complex-trait selection signal in the dataset—was strongest between about 4,000 and 2,000 years ago and much weaker afterward, fitting the broader pattern of the Bronze Age being an inflection point for many selected traits.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“Europeans have gotten lighter skin over the last 10,000 years... The period of strongest depigmentation is between about 4,000 to 2,000 years ago, and then after that it's much less.”

0.39

The shared cluster of correlated traits (schooling, obesity, walking pace, wealth, age at first birth) may reflect an ecological toggle between two reproductive strategies—few children with high investment (deferred reproduction, more resources per child) versus many children with low investment—analogous to mammal-versus-fish reproductive strategies, with the favored strategy and thus the direction of selection flipping depending on environmental conditions like times of plenty.

causalspeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“There's a toggle between having more kids and investing less in them, and having fewer kids and investing more in excelling in various ways.”

0.39

Although hunter-gatherers experienced boom-and-bust nutrition (gorging after a hunt, then days without meat), selection against body-fat storage in farmers makes sense because famine operates on a multi-year timescale while fat stores only carry one through weeks—surviving a famine three years later is a different problem than bridging the gap to the next hunt, so the two food-instability regimes select differently.

causalspeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“Your fat store from the latest hunt is not going to carry you through to the famine three years later. Survival of famines is a different thing than building up body fat to be able to survive two weeks later.”

0.39

The current consensus model of archaic-modern human relationships has, like Ptolemaic astronomy, accreted ever more complications (the modern-into-Neanderthal mixture, super-divergent lineages into Denisovans, invoking selection to explain odd mtDNA/Y patterns) to patch contradictions while insisting the whole genome 'truth' is that Neanderthals and Denisovans are sisters; Reich's swamping model is a Copernican simplification that explains more facts with no more complexity and is, in his view, much more plausible.

normativespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“We've patched it all together and gotten it all to work... It reminds one of what happened in the ancient world, where there was this idea that the sun revolves around the Earth, but it doesn't quite explain the movements of the planets properly.”

0.38

Migration produces enormous shifts in trait predictors: European hunter-gatherers sit about three standard deviations below the modern mean on the cognitive-performance predictor, farmers jump to the mean, and steppe pastoralists have a lower set value—these huge fluctuations reflect different population set points (migration), not selection, which is the consistent directional overlay the new test detects on top of them.

factualcontestednovelty 3/4durability 2/4· David Reich

“the estimate for the hunter-gatherers of Europe is three standard deviations below the modern mean... Then you see a huge jump from them to the farmers, who are at the mean, at zero. That's migration.”

0.36

The ancient DNA field was made possible by a roughly millionfold drop in sequencing cost since the late 2000s (plus another one-to-two orders of magnitude from 2010 to today), driving reported ancient human sequences from ~10 in 2010 to more than 20,000 today—several orders of magnitude that fundamentally changed which questions could be asked and answered.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· David Reich

“The drop in cost has been a millionfold since the late 2000s, and another maybe one to two orders of magnitude from 2010 to today.”

0.35

Schizophrenia and bipolar disorder risk variants may persist because they are a readout of a spectrum of traits—anxiety, imagination, creativity, propensity to visions—that can be advantageous in certain contexts like shamanistic or religious traditions, with subclinical versions favored at some times and disfavored at others, though most such mutations are low-frequency and small-effect, indicating they are predominantly disadvantageous.

causalspeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 2/4· David Reich

“Maybe being anxious, imaginative, or neurotic might be helpful in a shamanistic tradition or a religious tradition which values people who can have visions or be creative.”

0.35

The second uniparental marker could be retained through social selection: because men in traditional societies vary enormously in reproductive success (many have no children while a few have many), female mate choice becomes important, and offspring of archaic fathers may fare worse in competition for local females—a simple social-discrimination mechanism for which there is analogy in differential treatment of children by parental group in Central African rainforest hunter-gatherers.

causalspeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 2/4· David Reich

“men in traditional societies are actually very variable in their reproductive success. A large fraction of men never have kids... female mate choice begins to be an important process.”

0.33

A matrilineal (or patrilineal) expansion can explain why one uniparental marker is shared between Neanderthals and modern humans: if an expanding modern population raised children in the mothers' culture and incorporated local males, it retains its mitochondrial DNA (or, if patrilineal, its Y chromosome) even as the rest of its genome is swamped—solving one of the two uniparental puzzles, with the other requiring an additional explanation like natural or social selection.

causalspeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· David Reich

“If it's matrilineal, when they incorporate a male from the local community, he's brought into the community, and the kids are raised based on the culture of the mothers... it guarantees that one of these two parts of the genome looks like it does”

0.33

The genetic predictor of years of schooling correlates with surprisingly disparate traits—age at first childbirth, obesity, walking pace, household wealth—suggesting it taps some general trait better thought of as executive function or propensity to defer gratification, which gets pushed in the same direction across these traits and is advantageous or disadvantageous at different times rather than being 'intelligence' as commonly conceived.

definitionspeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 2/4· David Reich

“There seems to be some kind of general trait that you could maybe think of as executive function or a propensity to defer gratification... that is under selection.”

0.31

Because intelligence has not been the dominant trait under selection in humans (immune and metabolic traits dominated, especially post-Bronze Age), there is likely substantial 'room at the top'—as with height, pushing any of these complex traits harder in one direction would move the population mean well beyond present values, though probably at the cost of trade-offs with other traits.

forecastspeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· David Reich

“I think there's more room at the top for a lot of these traits. You can move height extremely in one direction, much more than it is today.”

0.28

Modern society's intense valuation of intelligence (IQ-test performance, years of schooling) is historically unprecedented: scripture like the Hebrew and Christian Bible and texts like Homer prized strength, courage, religiosity and beauty rather than smarts, so a hyper-focus on cognitive ability is not a value system common across human history.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· David Reich

“If you look at the Hebrew and Christian Bible, and you look at how much intelligence is valued, it's basically not at all.”

0.24

Reich describes himself as a geneticist who works on human history and how ancient people relate to each other and to people living today.

definitionestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· David Reich

“I'm a geneticist, and I work on human history and how ancient people relate to each other and people living today.”