evidence-based medicine
An approach to medical practice that bases decisions on systematic evidence from research, critiqued here as often actually opinion-based
As defined in Eric Topol on the Creative Destruction of Medicine
Where it comes up · 5
- Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal3 claims
- Steven Lipstein on Hospitals 12/08/20082 claims
- A conversation between Nassim Nicholas Taleb and Stephen Wolfram at the Wolfram Summer School 20211 claim
- Eric Topol on the Creative Destruction of Medicine1 claim
- Daphne Koller on Education, Coursera, and MOOCs1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “evidence-based medicine” →
- In both evidence-based medicine and evidence-based economics, the data never simply speak for themselves; you always need some theory in the background to interpret evidence, and even experts trained for decades can honestly disagree about what the same study means.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
- Personalized medicine using genetics holds enormous promise but increases the temptation to assume a drug works because of how it acts on a gene; because therapies will generalize to smaller and smaller groups, each must be tested on those small groups, making randomized trials and evidence-based medicine even more important rather than less.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
- Data-driven medicine goes beyond evidence-based medicine by feeding unbiased data into machine learning without a preconceived hypothesis, letting the data identify which features matter; applied to breast cancer this revealed that features surrounding the cancer cells are more predictive of prognosis than features of the cancer cells themselves.Daphne Koller on Education, Coursera, and MOOCs
- Much of what is called 'evidence-based medicine' is really 'eminence-based medicine'—a group of experts sitting in a room forming opinions that all patients with a given diagnosis should receive a certain treatment—and this approach does not work because the underlying evidence is scant.Eric Topol on the Creative Destruction of Medicine
- Because reversal partly stems from learning biochemistry and pathophysiology first—which convinces students everything works mechanistically as theorized—medical education should be flipped to teach evidence-based medicine first, presenting students with patients and cases and asking them to research the best-supported treatment, then teaching the underlying science later as a lens viewed through clinical experience.Adam Cifu on Ending Medical Reversal
- Medicine confuses evidence-based aggregate statistics with individual treatment, incorrectly generalizing claims about populations to individuals; the proper framework requires three separate methodologies: clinical (apprenticeship-based), empirical (statistical), and theoretical (mechanistic), each with different validity domains.A conversation between Nassim Nicholas Taleb and Stephen Wolfram at the Wolfram Summer School 2021
- Evidence-based medicine means using known best practice and ensuring it is applied consistently, and physicians' habits such as 'I've always done it this way' resist this, but senior physicians' accumulated experience is valuable, so the goal is an environment where learning and innovation feed each other.Steven Lipstein on Hospitals 12/08/2008
- Older physicians have accumulated experience that is extremely valuable, and cultural resistance to change, such as 'I've always done it this way,' is driven partly by differing familiarity with electronic technology across physician generations.Steven Lipstein on Hospitals 12/08/2008