
Steven Lipstein on Hospitals 12/08/2008
What this covers
Russ Roberts interviews Steven Lipstein, head of the St. Louis system BJC HealthCare, about how hospitals actually run. Lipstein explains why a $40 aspirin is not a real price: the charge carries the costs of uninsured patients, training doctors and nurses, regulatory compliance, and government underpayment. He also gives the finances. Hospitals need roughly a 3% operating margin, and about 9 to 10% of revenue once capital spending is counted.
The middle of the conversation covers operations. Lipstein attributes growing specialization to the explosion of genetic knowledge, and notes that every extra handoff between doctors creates a chance for coordination to fail. He says Medicare's payment weights favor procedures over primary care, which produces shortages in one and surpluses in the other. He also argues that a competitive system duplicates expensive equipment, contrasting one Canadian province with a single St. Louis road. BJC's Lean and Six Sigma program is set against Roberts's questions about measurement, such as door-to-balloon time and the costly X-rays that some pneumonia metrics would require. Roberts presses on nonprofit governance, arguing that without a profit-and-loss signal nothing disciplines risk-taking, and brings in Hayek's warning about overconfident design.
Contentious ground comes late. Lipstein argues that higher deductibles and co-payments push patients to forgo care whose cost resurfaces later. He also cites an end-of-life chemotherapy case and his estimate of $300 billion in excess annual spending from fragmented payment. The closing exchange tests the Federal Reserve analogy for a health board. Roberts stresses insulation from lobbying, while Lipstein doubts that such insulation is achievable.
Lipstein argues US hospital list prices are largely meaningless because they are shaped by legislated government rates, negotiated insurer discounts, and cross-subsidies, so reform needs a long-horizon, Fed-style governing board rather than piecemeal consumer cost-sharing.
- Medicare and Medicaid prices are set by legislation, not supply and demand, and commercial prices absorb the shortfall
- Negotiated discounts push list prices up, so a 50% discount on a $200 price yields the same $100 as full price
- A Congress-chartered Health Board with guiding principles could insulate health policy from short election cycles and special interests, as the Federal Reserve is insulated
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Because Medicare and Medicaid pay less than hospital costs, hospitals shift the uncovered cost onto commercial payers, so the commercial side ends up with very inflated prices that cover government underpayments as well as the deep discounts insurers negotiate.
“if we can't cover our cost from Medicare and from Medicaid we shift that burden to the commercial payers as well”
Commercial insurers negotiate percentage discounts off hospital list prices, and because the discounts keep growing, hospitals must raise list prices to hold the same net revenue: a 2% discount on a $100 price yields $98, but a 50% discount requires a $200 price to net the same $100.
“if the original price was $100 and the insurer wanted at a two percent discount then the effective revenue to the hospital was $98 ... if the insurer won at a 50% discount you can see that the price would grow to $200”
Hospital charges like orange juice or a $40 aspirin tablet are not meaningful prices; they embed the costs of the hospital's social missions, including caring for uninsured patients, training doctors and nurses, complying with regulation, and absorbing government underpayment, so bringing your own supplies would not lower the bill by the item's cost.
“when you add all the costs of our social missions caring for the poor and the uninsured caring educating the next generation of healthcare professionals complying with rules and regulations and delivering that aspirin tablet to the patient's bedside”
Profit induces risk-taking by owners and losses induce prudence, and a nonprofit lacks this feedback loop because the community does not judge the bottom line, hire or fire the CEO, or set pay.
“the role of profit and loss is to induce prudent risk taking on the part of owners ... I like to say the profit induces risk-taking that's the upside and the loss is what induces prudence”
Friedrich Hayek's point in The Fatal Conceit is that economics shows how little people know about what they imagine they can design, and the US suffers from a surfeit of design in its healthcare system.
“the curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design and we I think suffer from a surfeit of design”
Hospitals need about a 3% operating margin, and with non-cash depreciation they need roughly 9 to 10% of revenue to fund capital expenditures; BJC generates about 6% of this from depreciation and about 3% from its operating margin.
“hospitals by and large need to generate about a three percent operating margin ... about nine to ten percent of revenue that helps them to meet their capital expenditure obligations”
The growth of specialization increases the number of handoffs between doctors, and each handoff creates opportunities for care coordination failures, so more specialists lower overall care effectiveness even as each specialist knows more.
“the more handoffs you have between doctors and professionals and specialists the the greater opportunity there is for failures of care coordination”
Patients who do not pay for a service do not get asked whether they want the expensive option, so when insurance covers the cost, low-cost alternatives are rarely offered and expensive technology becomes the default.
“he didn't even ask me if I wanted it right it's never an option in most of these situations”
Measuring processes of care, such as door-to-balloon time for heart attacks, reveals failures that otherwise go unnoticed, but measures must be chosen carefully because some diagnostic measures, like requiring X-rays for all congestion patients, are very expensive.
“some hospitals have a they want to measure the proportion of their congestion patients who get an x-ray so they can avoid missing a pneumonia diagnosis but of course that's really expensive”
Because insurance pays most bills, patients and providers have no incentive to scrutinize or reduce individual charges, so a patient bringing their own supplies would not reduce the bill.
“certainly I had no incentive to bring my own orange juice or bring my own aspirin”
In a competitive rather than regulated health care model, hospitals duplicate expensive equipment: a piece of medical technology found once in the whole Canadian province of Saskatchewan may be found eight or nine times on Ballas Road in St. Louis.
“where you might find one kind of this particular piece of medical equipment in the whole province of Saskatchewan in Canada you may find eight or nine pieces of that same medical technology on Ballas Road here in st. Louis”
BJC uses 68 Lean and Six Sigma black belts to eliminate waste and variability; by standardizing steps, hospitals can automate parts of the process so every patient gets the right care every time.
“we have 68 black belts on our staff ... if we can eliminate waste or unnecessary steps in a medical care process if we can eliminate variability from hospital to hospital”
Designing the health system through central plans is subject to the 'fatal conceit' that people overestimate how well they can design complex systems, so structural reform may be a step in the right direction but its effect is hard to predict.
“I am drawn to the quote from high x book the fatal conceit the curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design”
A technology that improves imaging quality by only 1% but doubles the cost of imaging is a bad investment, so hospitals must weigh the benefit to a small share of patients against the incremental cost.
“if they're you know 1% improvement in the quality of imaging that doubles the cost of imaging is a bad investment”
HIPAA privacy rules sometimes prevent sharing medical information among clinicians that should be shared, so hospitals must balance confidentiality with making critical records available to emergency rooms when needed.
“in protecting patient confidentiality we sometimes don't share information among clinicians that perhaps we should”
Medicare's relative value unit payment system weights procedural services disproportionately, so specialists earn far more than primary care physicians, which artificially creates shortages of primary care doctors and surpluses in procedural fields.
“it's a function of the way Medicare pays doctors based on work RV use or relative value units ... those value units are weighted and they are disproportionately weighted to the specialties that have procedures involved”
The US spends an estimated $300 billion more per year than other developed nations because of its fragmented system of paying for health care, with separate Medicare, state-specific Medicaid, and hundreds of insurer-specific commercial contracts creating a outdated revenue cycle.
“there are estimates that we as a nation spend 300 billion dollars more than they would spend in other developed nations because we have we have this very fragmented system of paying for health care services”
Higher deductibles and co-payments make patients forgo or postpone needed care, and the cost of that forgone care reappears later as avoidable hospitalizations, complications and more expensive treatment, so cost-sharing saves money now but shifts cost to others later.
“out-of-pocket cost sharing by the typical American is is causing people to really forestall or to postpone needed health care services ... people end up in the hospital for avoidable medical conditions”
Medical specialization has intensified because of an explosion of knowledge, including genetic information: the roughly 30,000 gene pairs differ slightly between people, so two patients with diabetes may need different treatments because their mutations differ, which pushes medicine toward narrower expertise.
“there are something like thirty you know thirty thousand plus gene pairs in the in the human anatomy ... the mutation which causes your diabetes in your genes is different than the one that causes mine”
Data-driven measurement can improve care, but it can also be costly or misused: measuring pneumonia requires x-rays for many congestion patients at high expense, and hand-washing data show that doctors who wash more get better results.
“some hospitals have a they want to measure the proportion of their congestion patients who get an x-ray so they can avoid missing a pneumonia diagnosis but of course that's really expensive”
Federal Reserve governors serve 14-year terms and the Fed's monetary policy work is largely insulated from political influence, with no lobbyist or special interest directly influencing the federal funds rate.
“the seven people who are appointed to the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve are appointed for terms of 14 years which is longer than the term of a congressman”
Politicization and special-interest lobbying have repeatedly derailed or influenced health care reform, so a structure insulated from political pressure, like the Fed, is needed to design solutions over a longer timeframe.
“our attempts at reforming the American healthcare system have always been either influenced or perhaps even outright led derailed by special interests”
The Fed analogy is imperfect: lobbying may have spared health care from some mistakes, the Fed's deliberate actions have been mixed, and without a central bank the economy might be in worse shape, so a politically insulated health board may be an illusion.
“I think we've probably been spared some mistakes in health care designed by lobbying so it's probably a little more of a mixed bag”
Medicare's coverage of end-of-life chemotherapy led a patient to pursue aggressive treatment for a roughly 20% chance of benefit, even though her prognosis was an 80% likelihood of dying within two years, because the cost was not a financial burden to her or her children.
“because Medicare does cover that end-of-life care and treatment she felt that she wanted to see if she would be one of the 20% to benefit from that chemotherapy”
A US Health Board modeled on the Federal Reserve, chartered by Congress with guiding principles of guaranteed affordable access, affordable premiums and out-of-pocket costs, and choice of doctors, hospitals and insurers, could delegate health insurance regulation and shield it from short-term politics.
“one of the models that I have become really interested in is the federal reserve model of creating a Health Board or a health policy board for the United States that is chartered and legally chartered by Congress”
Hospital goals conflict and must be balanced, and the balance has to include financial, physical and human assets, because buildings do not take care of patients, people do, so a hospital is a people industry rather than a production industry.
“buildings don't take care of patients people do ... we're not a production industry so much as we are an industry of people taking care of other people”
A nonprofit hospital CEO is accountable in practice to patients and to a community Board of Trustees, not to shareholders, and the board's expectations are four key result areas: taking very good care of patients, operating financially responsibly, positioning hospitals to last a long time, and staying true to social and academic missions.
“we call those our four key result areas taking very good care of patients operating in a financially responsible way positioning the hospitals to be around for a long time and staying true to our social and our academic mission”
Technology adoption at BJC is driven less by payer demand than by intellectual curiosity and the academic mission of an affiliate of Washington University School of Medicine, so new technologies are often studied as they are applied rather than simply bought when reimbursed.
“it's driven by a desire to create new knowledge and to understand better which technologies work well ... we're studying these technologies as much as we're applying them at the bedside”
Election cycles of two years for Congress and four or eight years for a president give the US health system too short a planning horizon, and a long-term planning horizon is the foundation needed to fix the system's problems.
“the long-term planning horizon to set up a long-term planning horizon for the American healthcare system which cannot be every other year election cycles”
Patients who manage their own consolidated health records, such as Lipstein's family records on the MyHealthFolders platform, can access records across many separate physician electronic health record systems and share them in an emergency, with the trade-off of security risk that is mitigated by encryption and changing PINs.
“we would be on 15 different electronic health record platforms where by taking responsibility for managing some of our own medical information we have it in one place”
Patients and families should take an active role in coordinating care, including knowing their medications and which physicians talk to each other, because primary care physicians cannot be relied on as the coordinator when patients see them fewer than nine times in nine years.
“I've lived in st. Louis now for nine years and I have visited with my boy my primary care physician fewer than nine times ... I need to take a more active role in coordinating my own care”
Insurance mandates require employers offering insurance to cover a minimum set of services, such as maternity care with a second night in hospital, so the cost is spread through premiums and an implicit subsidy from taxpayers and other insured people.
“if you offer insurance it's got to include a certain minimum number of things ... a second day night in the hospital which my wife really appreciate it and was paid for of course by taxpayers and and others in that implicit implicit subsidy”
BJC's Center for Healthcare Quality and Effectiveness measures processes such as door-to-balloon time, hand-washing frequency and antibiotic timing, because hand-washing frequency correlates with infection rates and timeliness and accuracy correlate with outcomes.
“we measure the frequency of hand washing because hand washing is correlated with rates of infection we measure the rate at which we administer antibiotics”
Not-for-profit and for-profit hospitals both must generate operating surpluses; the key difference is that for-profits distribute earnings to owners and investors while not-for-profits must retain earnings for community benefit.
“both not-for-profit and for-profit companies do generate an operating surplus ... the big difference is that for-profit companies for-profit hospitals are able to distribute their earnings to individuals”
Hospitalists, who spend all their time in the hospital, coordinate inpatient care, but their model breaks down at the handoff between the hospital and the community primary care physician, and so care coordination failure persists at the boundary of episodes.
“the advantage of having a hospitalist is he or she is a coordinating physician among of all the care you would receive while you're in the hospital but the problem is is that as you know episodes of care go beyond the hospital setting”
Patients with insurance encounter a 'free' procedure as costless, so demand for it is higher; when patients pay out of pocket, demand falls, which is the economic rationale for cost-sharing that Lipstein says creates a dilemma for care decisions.
“the economic theory being that anything that is free will have higher demand that anything that costs money”
Hospital prices have little meaning inside the industry anymore because very few payers actually pay the list price, if any do, and the resulting system does not make much sense, which is why reform looks attractive to many people.
“the prices mean very little inside the industry anymore very few payers actually pay less price if any”
Measurement-driven process improvement at BJC moved about 50% of its measured indicators into the top 10% nationally, and the rate of administering thrombolytics to heart attack patients in the emergency room improved from 30 minutes to a shorter timeframe.
“about 50% of our measured indicators are in the top 10% nationally ... if we used to be able to get those medicines administered in 30 minutes now we're getting them in a shorter timeframe”
Evidence-based medicine means using known best practice and ensuring it is applied consistently, and physicians' habits such as 'I've always done it this way' resist this, but senior physicians' accumulated experience is valuable, so the goal is an environment where learning and innovation feed each other.
“what we call evidence-based medicine where we use what we what we already know and make sure that we're doing it consistently”
The shortage of primary care physicians is driven by lower pay and by lifestyle and work-life balance concerns, which make primary care less attractive to new doctors.
“there's a real shortage now of primary care physicians and because not only is it less remunerative but there are fewer and fewer doctors pursuing careers in primary care because of the lifestyle”
People, including medical professionals, have great difficulty reasoning about uncertainty and probability, which makes end-of-life medical decisions especially hard.
“uncertainty and probability you're not the average person strong suit and in my experience they're not always the medical profession strong suit”
Hospitals discourage patients from bringing medications from home because administration of medications in a hospital is governed by rules, regulations and laws, so 'bring your own' savings are not a practical way to cut costs.
“typically we in the hospital environment we don't encourage people to bring medications from home because we we there are rules and regulations and laws that govern the administration of medications”
New drugs and devices must get FDA approval, and once approved they are typically covered by insurers, Medicare and Medicaid because they are no longer considered experimental, so hospitals then judge financial feasibility by projected volume and revenue.
“the equipment and the technology has to be approved in our country by the Food and Drug Administration ... once devices and where equipment or new drugs become fda-approved typically they've become covered by the insurance companies”
About 30% of BJC's revenue comes from Medicare and about 13% from Medicaid, and for these two programs hospitals do not set prices; the prices are legislated based on the availability of government funds rather than cost of goods, supply and demand.
“about 30 percent of the revenue that we take in as a health system comes from the federal government through Medicare ... about 13% of our revenue comes from Medicaid”
A large share of American households, 55%, earn under $50,000 a year, so rising gas, food and energy prices and high deductibles make them forgo care they cannot afford.
“in America right now 55 percent of American households will you know earn under $50,000 a year”
A nonprofit CEO is accountable in the abstract to patients and a community-representative Board of Trustees, not to shareholders, so there is no market-style feedback loop judging the CEO's performance.
“I've always kind of felt that as the CEO BGC I'm accountable to our patients and I a board there's a Board of Trustees that is representative of the community”
Lipstein argues that the Federal Reserve reformed model is attractive as a planning institution, but he is unsure whether the proposed health board would be free of political pressure at all.
“it may be an illusion to think there could ever be such a board either at the Fed or in the health world that is not subject to political pressure”
Older physicians have accumulated experience that is extremely valuable, and cultural resistance to change, such as 'I've always done it this way,' is driven partly by differing familiarity with electronic technology across physician generations.
“some are much more facile with using electronic technology than others ... our more senior physicians have accumulated a careers worth of experience”
For-profit Tenet Health Care can take earnings from its St. Louis University Hospital and Veterans Hospital back to headquarters in Dallas, reallocate them to hospitals elsewhere, or distribute them to shareholders, while BJC keeps its earnings in its own local geography.
“the earnings from those hospitals could be taken back to headquarters in Dallas it could be reallocated to other hospitals that tenant owns across the country”
Medicare accounts for about 30 percent of BJC HealthCare's revenue and Medicaid for about 13 percent, with commercial managed care payers making up the balance of patient service revenue.
“about 30 percent of the revenue that we take in as a health system comes from the federal government through Medicare”
Max Baucus's 89-page white paper on US healthcare reform identifies a large volume and complexity of problems, so the core obstacle to reform is the complexity itself rather than disagreement with any particular argument.
“max baucus who is the chairman of the Senate Finance Committee just came out with an 89 page white paper”