epiphenomenon
A secondary phenomenon that accompanies physical processes but has no causal effect on them, as in the view that consciousness is a mere by-product of brain activity.
As defined in ms_ama_may_2024
Where it comes up · 10
- 164 - Cause Effect2 claims
- 135 - Navigating Sex And Gender2 claims
- 235 - A Call From Ricky Gervais1 claim
- 239 - Yet Another Call From Ricky Gervais1 claim
- 102 - Is Buddhism True1 claim
- 475 - The Hard Problem Of Consciousness1 claim
- 159 - Conscious1 claim
- 30 - Inside The Crucible Syria And The Islamic State1 claim
and 2 more
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “epiphenomenon” →
- Even the notion of space may be an approximation to something far stranger; in certain modern quantum gravity approaches, equations exist in which space is an epiphenomenon or emergent concept, with the fundamental starting point being a large collection of objects that have no notion of space at all.268 | Matt Strassler on Relativity, Fields, and the Language of Reality
- Emergent higher-level phenomena (minds, economies, desires) have no genuine top-down causal power; the causal efficacy always runs at the physical level — for example, the desire for coffee is experienced phenomenologically but only causes action via its neural instantiation linked to muscles — so apparent top-down causation is just a level of abstraction, not an independent causal layer.164 - Cause Effect
- It is possible that consciousness is an epiphenomenon—T.H. Huxley likened it to the steam whistle on a train, a super-salient feature of the train's operation that is doing absolutely nothing integral—a view that sounds counterintuitive but, Harris suggests, has long had a lot going for it.475 - The Hard Problem Of Consciousness
- Consciousness might be an epiphenomenon that does nothing causally—like the whistle on a steam engine that whistles without providing propulsive power (Huxley's analogy)—which would undercut any selective rationale for it, since natural selection cannot favor a trait that has no causal effect.174 - Life Mind
- Although it strongly feels as if consciousness drives our decisions and actions, the science suggests the opposite: anything we are conscious of—any deliberative choice in writing or planning—is preceded by unconscious events in the brain that have no conscious correlate, so consciousness may not be functioning as the cause it seems to be.159 - Conscious
- The 1980s idea that history was ending in a great riptide of liberal democracy is fantasy and dangerous utopian ground; history grinds on, the post-Cold War order has collapsed, Europe is again becoming a battleground, and a tactical or even intercontinental nuclear exchange is conceivable within a lifetime.30 - Inside The Crucible Syria And The Islamic State
- It is unknown whether the experiential, conscious component of dreaming is itself doing something functional or is merely a byproduct (epiphenomenon) of memory consolidation, since the brain accomplishes most of its maintenance work unconsciously, in the dark, without any accompanying experience.235 - A Call From Ricky Gervais
- Everything we know and notice about the mind from the first-person side — experience, sense of self, intelligence — is a product of what our brains, as physical information-processing systems, are doing.239 - Yet Another Call From Ricky Gervais
- Consciousness may be dissociable from intelligence: we could build superintelligent machines more competent than us on every task with no 'lights on' — nothing it is like to be them — because most of our own intelligent behavior (grammatical language, motor skills, blindsight visual discrimination) operates unconsciously, suggesting consciousness might even be an epiphenomenon not doing causal work.164 - Cause Effect
- Modern behavioral science implicitly treats subjective experience as evolutionarily superfluous and possibly epiphenomenal—influenced by the physical machinery but not influencing it, like a shadow to a hand—because if behavior can be fully explained by physical information processing (e.g., reflexively withdrawing a hand from fire), then the felt pain appears functionally insignificant, even though consciousness is the very thing that gives life moral meaning.102 - Is Buddhism True