causal

No Genuine Top-Down Causation

Emergent higher-level phenomena (minds, economies, desires) have no genuine top-down causal power; the causal efficacy always runs at the physical level — for example, the desire for coffee is experienced phenomenologically but only causes action via its neural instantiation linked to muscles — so apparent top-down causation is just a level of abstraction, not an independent causal layer.

causalpending

Speaker

Sam Harris

Evidence Quote

“the cash value of experience has to be run at the level of the physics of things”

Source

164 - Cause Effect— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:56:43 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...