enumerated powers
The constitutional principle that the federal government possesses only the specific powers listed in the Constitution, with all others reserved to the states.
As defined in Richard Epstein on the Constitution
Where it comes up · 4
- Richard Epstein on the Constitution4 claims
- Free culture1 claim
- Richard Epstein on Classical Liberalism, Libertarianism, and Lochner1 claim
- George Will on the Conservative Sensibility1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “enumerated powers” →
- A classical liberal constitution follows a two-part strategy: first shrink what is up for grabs in the public space so fewer unappropriated rents are available to political activists, and second build robust government institutions with veto gates that slow lawmaking, operating on the presumption that a statute is presumptively bad unless shown to be good.Richard Epstein on Classical Liberalism, Libertarianism, and Lochner
- Until the mid-1960s, Congress tried to anchor new programs in an enumerated constitutional power (as with the National Defense Highway and Education Acts), but James Q. Wilson's 'legitimacy barrier' finally fell with the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, after which government abandoned any pretense of limits on its proper scope and competence.George Will on the Conservative Sensibility
- The Supreme Court's rejection of Eldred v. Ashcroft (challenging the constitutionality of the Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act) represented a failure to apply the principles established in Lopez v. United States (requiring that enumerated powers have meaningful limits), thereby abandoning the constitutional requirement that copyright terms be 'limited'.Free culture
- 1937 was not primarily a response to the Great Depression but the culmination of a 40-year movement building since around 1900: progressives steadily expanded both federal commerce power (eventually allowing regulation of intrastate manufacturing, mining, and agriculture and propping up labor and agricultural cartels) and faith in expert administration, so the New Deal expansion reflected underlying forces rather than just crisis response.Richard Epstein on the Constitution
- In McCulloch v. Maryland John Marshall interpreted 'necessary and proper' to mean merely 'appropriate,' lowering the level of scrutiny on congressional action—'necessary' implies you can't do without it while 'appropriate' is a much looser connection—which let him uphold the national bank; Epstein thinks Marshall misread the clause, which traditionally would only supply ancillary powers (like housing stipends for D.C. residents) rather than serve as an elastic grant.Richard Epstein on the Constitution
- If you ask which constitutional provisions have durability outlasting their creation, a very large fraction do—especially the structure of enumerated powers and inter-state competition policed by federal anti-blockade power, which works as well in the age of the internet and airplane as in the horse-and-buggy era—while the ones that failed (the three-fifths clause and fugitive slave provisions) are all gone.Richard Epstein on the Constitution
- By 1937 everything changed: separation of powers was viewed with suspicion, the administrative state rose, and the enumerated-powers limit (especially the Commerce Clause) was scrapped for a system of concurrent jurisdiction in which the federal government can act on any important economic issue and the state can too—a huge shift from a lean classical state of small government and strong property rights to a law state with heavy administrative law and broad discretion at all levels.Richard Epstein on the Constitution