factual

Marshall Misread Necessary and Proper as Appropriate

In McCulloch v. Maryland John Marshall interpreted 'necessary and proper' to mean merely 'appropriate,' lowering the level of scrutiny on congressional action—'necessary' implies you can't do without it while 'appropriate' is a much looser connection—which let him uphold the national bank; Epstein thinks Marshall misread the clause, which traditionally would only supply ancillary powers (like housing stipends for D.C. residents) rather than serve as an elastic grant.

factualpending

Speaker

Richard Epstein

Evidence Quote

“My view is that I think Marshall misread the clause. He was in fact a champion of the strong Federal government.”

Source

Richard Epstein on the Constitution— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:11:58 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...