empiricist criterion of meaning
The principle that a factual claim has empirical meaning only if it can be traced back to original impressions from experience; terms without impressional foundations are meaningless
As defined in A History of Philosophy | 46 David Hume
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “empiricist criterion of meaning” →
- Hume uses the empiricist criterion of meaning to demolish abstract concepts by showing they have no basis in original impressions: necessary connection has no impression, miracles have no impression, abstract universal ideas have no impression, and the concept of mind/soul/substance has no impression.A History of Philosophy | 46 David Hume
- The empiricist criterion of meaning states that for a term to have factual, empirical meaning, it must refer to original impressions; if no original impression can be found for an idea, the idea has no empirical meaning.A History of Philosophy | 46 David Hume
- In a classroom discussion, a student argues that the empiricist criterion of meaning leads logically to nominalism, since without empirical impressions of abstract entities, general terms cannot refer to universals but only to custom-based groupings of particulars.A History of Philosophy | 46 David Hume
- The big question in Hume's epistemology is how we have knowledge of matters of fact, where the empiricist criterion of meaning becomes most important, and this question is developed in section four of the Inquiry, which is the crucial section.A History of Philosophy | 46 David Hume
- In 20th century philosophy, the two crucial issues arising from the empiricist criterion of meaning were what it does to moral language and what it does to religious language.A History of Philosophy | 46 David Hume
- The empiricist criterion of meaning was challenged starting in the 1940s and substantially by the 1950s-1960s, not from conceptualists defending abstract ideas, but from those who argued empiricists were not empirical enough about the diversity of language.A History of Philosophy | 46 David Hume
- After understanding Hume's empiricist criterion of meaning, the rest of his philosophy appears to be a mopping-up operation: the basic question is not 'can you prove X' but 'what in experience are you talking about'—a question of empirical meaningfulness rather than truth.A History of Philosophy | 46 David Hume
- Hume's empiricist criterion of meaning was adopted and updated by 20th century logical empiricists, most notably A.J. Ayer in Language, Truth and Logic.A History of Philosophy | 46 David Hume