economic surplus
The gap between what someone would be willing to pay for something and what they actually pay; total surplus is the measure economists use to judge efficiency.
As defined in Robert Frank on Coase
Other definitions
The cumulative sum across people of the difference between benefits received and costs borne, measured in each person's own terms; the consequentialist metric economists use to judge outcomes.
Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
Where it comes up · 2
- Robert Frank on Coase6 claims
- Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/20106 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “economic surplus” →
- Frank no longer teaches the dead-weight-loss surplus calculus because it implicitly assumes all gains can be measured in dollars, and the promise that gains can be redistributed later leaves unanswered what it means for society to be better off when no redistribution occurs.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- Judging policies only by total surplus is too narrow: a society that enslaved people might have high measured productivity, yet no one would freely agree to such rules at the outset, so legitimate rules must be ones everyone would accept ex ante.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- The 'bigger pie, then redistribute' argument has a problem: if the pie is not actually redistributed, it is unclear what it means to say society is better off, so the compensation logic cannot justify policies on its own.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- Making the economic pie bigger is always attractive because it makes it possible for everyone to have a bigger slice, and choosing the larger surplus requires no difficult value judgment.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- Cost-benefit and Coasean analysis are distorted by income differences because willingness to pay scales with wealth: a poor violinist might value playing at night greatly in psychological terms but only pay $5, while a wealthy neighbor mildly inconvenienced might pay $10,000 to stop it, so the wealthy person's preference dominates the calculation despite his smaller real harm.Robert Frank on Coase
- Efficiency analysis tells you how big the surplus pie is but ignores who gets which slices, yet people care critically about their own share, not just the total — so whether parties will agree to an efficiency-enhancing change often depends on how individual shares are affected.Robert Frank on Coase
- Economists favor the efficiency argument for free trade largely because it is elegant and exam-friendly, but the fact that trade maximizes the pie is not a convincing argument for most people and arguably should not be, because the welfare of poorer and lower-skilled individuals also matters.Robert Frank on Coase
- The cheapest way to resolve an externality is in a profound sense the morally right solution, because any more expensive resolution leaves surplus on the table such that both parties could have been made better off — so moral intuitions that reject the cheap solution have simply failed to identify the right answer.Robert Frank on Coase
- Free trade makes the total surplus bigger but can shrink labor's share, so absent compensating transfers from the gainers (capital) to losers (labor) it is not irrational for labor to vote against free trade — and the efficiency argument alone is therefore not a convincing case for it.Robert Frank on Coase
- To an economist a situation is efficient if it produces the largest possible economic surplus, where surplus is the gap between what someone would be willing to pay and what they actually pay; if things can be rearranged to make total surplus bigger, the situation cannot be efficient.Robert Frank on Coase