economic calculation
The use of money prices and profit-and-loss accounting to compare the relative value of alternative production projects and decide which use of scarce resources is most worthwhile.
As defined in Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)
Where it comes up · 4
- Peter Boettke on Mises3 claims
- Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)2 claims
- Peter Boettke on Living Economics1 claim
- Javier Milei1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “economic calculation” →
- Mises's calculation argument is distinct from and stronger than the incentive critique of socialism: granting for the sake of argument that a 'Socialist Man' is transformed to work selflessly for the common good, socialism still fails because without private property in the means of production there are no markets and no prices for those means, leaving the planner unable to calculate how to allocate scarce resources among competing ends—so socialism cannot achieve its own ends.Peter Boettke on Mises
- The defining intellectual project of mainline economics is reconciling the self-interest postulate (individuals pursue what they want as best they can, which is not selfishness or lightning calculation) with the invisible hand (self-regulating market outcomes), and the reconciliation is achieved through institutional analysis — specifically the private property, market economy — not through assumptions that any self-interested behavior under any circumstances yields good outcomes.Peter Boettke on Living Economics
- The function of economic calculation is to sort, from the array of technologically feasible projects, those which are economically viable—because many technically possible options have costs exceeding benefits, and only the price system provides the mechanism to identify which feasible projects are worthwhile.Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)
- The bottom line of Mises's Socialism is a syllogism: without private property in the means of production there is no market in the means of production; without a market there are no prices for those means; and without prices reflecting relative scarcities there is no way for an economic planner to allocate scarce resources among competing ends.Peter Boettke on Mises
- Mises argued in 1920 that abolishing private property in the means of production abolishes markets in the means of production, which abolishes relative prices; without relative prices indicating relative scarcities, planners cannot perform economic calculation to choose between investment projects, so socialism would systematically produce less with more rather than more with less, failing on its own productivity terms.Who Won the Socialist Calculation Debate (with Peter Boettke)
- The collapse of socialism revealed 'negative value-added firms'—firms where the value of inputs exceeded the value of the outputs they produced—which is a calculational failure rather than merely an incentive failure, demonstrating that planners lacked real prices and thus could not calculate the efficient use of resources.Peter Boettke on Mises
- Milei defines the market as a process of voluntary exchange where individuals cooperate by transferring property rights under upheld private property; since (per Mises) without private property there are no prices and thus no economic calculation, resources get misallocated—so free-market capitalism is the best mechanism ever developed for resource allocation, illustrated by why roads are built of asphalt rather than gold.Javier Milei