ecological rationality
The study of which environments a given decision tool (heuristic or analytic) works well in and which it fails in; a term also used by Vernon Smith.
As defined in Gerd Gigerenzer on Gut Feelings
Other definitions
The hypothesis that heuristics and decision-making rules that appear 'irrational' in laboratory settings are actually optimal adaptations to the structure of the environment in which they evolved
Nassim Taleb — Meditations on Extremistan
Where it comes up · 4
- Vernon Smith on Rationality in Economics 03/03/20089 claims
- In Defense of Intuition (with Gerd Gigerenzer)2 claims
- Gerd Gigerenzer on Gut Feelings1 claim
- 227 | Molly Crockett on the Psychology of Morality1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 13Search all claims for “ecological rationality” →
- Experimental subjects who find competitive equilibrium cannot model their own decision process and give blank stares when asked how they did it, showing that humans can function well in rule-governed systems while being very poor at modeling the process that produces their success.Vernon Smith on Rationality in Economics 03/03/2008
- Smith's book states that we can never fully understand how the process of market prices works in the world, because the information required is not given or available to any one mind, which makes evaluating policy require methods beyond traditional economics.Vernon Smith on Rationality in Economics 03/03/2008
- Heuristics can fail or excel, and the key question is ecological rationality—identifying the situation where a tool will likely work and where it won't; this is not special to heuristics, since analytic and statistical methods like Value at Risk or rating-agency models also produce excellent results or total failures, so every tool (heuristic or analytic) is good for one environment and bad for another, like a hammer needing a nail not a screw.Gerd Gigerenzer on Gut Feelings
- Experiment subjects who find the competitive equilibrium cannot explain how they did it, and even when shown that no one could do better given others' behavior, they cannot model their own decision process; humans are very good at functioning in rule-governed systems but very hard to model.Vernon Smith on Rationality in Economics 03/03/2008
- Deontological reasoning is highly rational in a social sense because deontological reasoners are seen as more trustworthy social partners; close relationships are premised on prioritization, so people overwhelmingly prefer deontological reasoners over utilitarians as spouses and best friends—challenging the view that deontology is merely an irrational intuition.227 | Molly Crockett on the Psychology of Morality
- It is puzzling that individual traders use limited reason in actual markets, yet the overall system behaves with surprising rationality; the theory of equilibrium rests on theorists' reasoning, not on what participants consciously calculate.Vernon Smith on Rationality in Economics 03/03/2008
- Ecological equilibrium arises when people, through repeated trade over time using their own devices and whatever trading institution exists, reach outcomes that match the supply and demand model's prices and volumes, even though they never model the process themselves.Vernon Smith on Rationality in Economics 03/03/2008
- Ecological rationality is the process in which people using their own devices in repeated trade over time reach the price and volume predicted by the supply and demand model, and the outcome can be called rational because the model explains why it is rational, even though real markets are a moving target.Vernon Smith on Rationality in Economics 03/03/2008
- A central theme of the book is that people solve many life problems, such as how to behave in a marketplace, in ways they do not understand themselves, yet produce outcomes with attractive properties.Vernon Smith on Rationality in Economics 03/03/2008
- The 'bias bias' is the temptation to see cognitive biases everywhere even when there are none; many famous biases (overconfidence, hot hand fallacy, conjunction error, base rate neglect, framing) are not biases at all but may be biased only in certain situations, and the framework has been misused to blame people and justify paternalism.In Defense of Intuition (with Gerd Gigerenzer)