doubling time
The time required for a quantity to double; used throughout as the key metric for the pace of compute, software progress, and robot-industry growth.
As defined in Carl Shulman (Pt 1) — Intelligence explosion, primate evolution, robot doublings, & alignment
Other definitions
In the context of AI capabilities, the rate at which AI system performance improvements occur, measured as the time it takes for models to progress through increasingly complex versions of benchmark tasks
AI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)
Where it comes up · 6
- Understanding the Most Viral Chart in Artificial Intelligence | Odd Lots3 claims
- Robin Hanson on the Technological Singularity 01/03/20113 claims
- A Historic Market Bubble1 claim
- Carl Shulman (Pt 1) — Intelligence explosion, primate evolution, robot doublings, & alignment1 claim
- Tyler Cowen on the Great Stagnation 2/14/20111 claim
- AI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “doubling time” →
- Farm and forest yields fell from about 6% to 3% during the 30-year repricing, and stock yields normal at 4.5% are now about 2%, so society compounds wealth half as fast, doubling every 24 years instead of every 12, which harms the young and the non-owners.A Historic Market Bubble
- Growth rate differences matter enormously: at 4 percent a year the average living standard doubles in about 18 years, at 3 percent in about 24, and at 2 percent in about 35.Tyler Cowen on the Great Stagnation 2/14/2011
- Over the past century world economic growth has been a steady roughly 4% per year, doubling about every 15 years, but over the longer history growth has been steady punctuated by a few sharp transitions (human emergence, farming about 10,000 years ago, industrialization about 200 years ago).Robin Hanson on the Technological Singularity 01/03/2011
- At each major transition the growth rate rose by a factor of roughly 200 or more, and the doubling time shrank from about a quarter million years, to about a thousand years, to about 15 years, with each change happening in a much shorter span than the previous doubling time.Robin Hanson on the Technological Singularity 01/03/2011
- Extrapolating the pattern of the three past transitions (with comparable step sizes and doubling counts per mode) implies the next transition would produce a world economy doubling every one to two weeks, while the timing is only loosely predictable, roughly within the next century.Robin Hanson on the Technological Singularity 01/03/2011
- Models can complete longer and longer tasks, with the doubling time for task length reaching approximately seven months in recent studies, suggesting exponential improvement in sustained reasoning capability.AI Timelines and Human Psychology (with Sarah Hastings-Woodhouse)
- Joel acknowledges that METR's baseline methodology is imperfect and would ideally have 100x more resources (100 baselines per task, top-tier engineers, wider task distributions), but current limitations don't invalidate the core finding of exponential progress because doubling time is robust to baseline variability.Understanding the Most Viral Chart in Artificial Intelligence | Odd Lots
- Choosing the shortest or longest observed baseline time from METR's measurement pool, rather than averaging, probably wouldn't change the final measurement significantly—it would just shift the absolute numbers, not the doubling rate that drives the headline findings.Understanding the Most Viral Chart in Artificial Intelligence | Odd Lots
- Because annual-doubling production must amortize a whole factory's capital cost in one year rather than ten — raising capital costs roughly tenfold — but the elimination of human cognitive labor, massive industrial scale-up, and AI-designed efficiency gains offset that increase, an AI-directed robot industrial base could plausibly achieve doubling times of months rather than years, since financial payback on a robot replacing a human worker would be on the order of weeks to months.Carl Shulman (Pt 1) — Intelligence explosion, primate evolution, robot doublings, & alignment
- There is a difference between 7-month and 4-month doubling times that matters more rhetorically than practically—if AI is destroying white-collar work in 2 years vs 3 years, the distinction is somewhat academic, but the underlying exponential pace is what matters.Understanding the Most Viral Chart in Artificial Intelligence | Odd Lots