doctrine of double effect
The ethical principle that an action with two effects—one intended and one merely foreseen—is judged differently depending on intention: it is one thing to do something foreseeing harm, another to aim at that harm as part of your plan.
As defined in Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Solved the Trolley Problem
Where it comes up · 2
- Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Solved the Trolley Problem5 claims
- 448 - The Philosophy Of Good And Evil1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “doctrine of double effect” →
- The trolley intuition is best explained by the doctrine of double effect (tracing to Aquinas): in the footbridge case you intend the man's death and use him as a means, whereas in the switch case you merely foresee but do not intend the one death—shown by the fact that you'd be delighted if the one on the spur escaped but dismayed if the pushed man bounced off harmlessly.448 - The Philosophy Of Good And Evil
- The trolley problem is an ancient dilemma traceable to the Cesarean section: in 200 AD, removing a baby from a dying mother's womb was understood to kill the mother for certain while possibly saving the baby—a weak Pareto-improvement that nonetheless involves actively killing one party, prefiguring the killing-versus-allowing distinction.Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Solved the Trolley Problem
- Although from a utilitarian or consequentialist perspective diverting a trolley to kill one to save five is equivalent to allowing five to die, people feel a real moral difference rooted in moral agency: actively killing someone is categorically different from allowing them to die.Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Solved the Trolley Problem
- Adam Smith, writing in 1759, effectively anticipated the trolley problem by showing that people feel a fundamental moral difference between actively causing harm and merely allowing it; his resolution of the little-finger puzzle via the impartial spectator and moral agency is the same distinction Philippa Foot later drew between allowing a death and killing.Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Solved the Trolley Problem
- The decision to drop atomic bombs on Japan was a real-world trolley problem: dropping the bomb meant intentionally killing defenseless civilians (active killing) versus pursuing Operation Downfall, a conventional invasion whose resistance would, as an unavoidable side-consequence, cause roughly ten times as many casualties—up to a million U.S. soldiers and as many as 50 million Japanese by Japan's own estimate.Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Solved the Trolley Problem
- In trolley surveys, when diverting would kill five to save one, virtually no one says they should act, whereas when diverting kills one to save five, responses differ—demonstrating that intention and the act of causing harm, not mere body count, drive moral judgment.Michael Munger on How Adam Smith Solved the Trolley Problem