causal

Doctrine of Double Effect Explains Trolley Intuition

The trolley intuition is best explained by the doctrine of double effect (tracing to Aquinas): in the footbridge case you intend the man's death and use him as a means, whereas in the switch case you merely foresee but do not intend the one death—shown by the fact that you'd be delighted if the one on the spur escaped but dismayed if the pushed man bounced off harmlessly.

causalpending

Speaker

David Edmonds

Evidence Quote

“imagine that you push the large man from the footbridge and the large man is wearing a rubber suit and instead of dying he bounces off the track and he runs away so what's your reaction to that case your reaction to that case is that's not good because the whole point of pushing him over was that so he got in the way of the train”

Source

448 - The Philosophy Of Good And Evil— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 2:04:20 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...