diminution in value
The loss in a property's market value caused by a government restriction, which is the measure used to assess whether a regulatory taking requires compensation.
As defined in Richard Epstein on Property Rights, Zoning and Kelo 9/17/2007
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “diminution in value” →
- Requiring compensation for restrictions that do not implicate nuisance would eliminate low-density gaming, because those imposing an 80 percent restriction on someone else's land would gain only about 10 percent themselves and would not indulge if they had to pay for it.Richard Epstein on Property Rights, Zoning and Kelo 9/17/2007
- Under the prevailing rule, unless a regulation wipes out all economically viable use of property, a phrase open to much interpretation, diminution in value is treated as a competitive loss for which no compensation is required.Richard Epstein on Property Rights, Zoning and Kelo 9/17/2007
- Under current doctrine, a reduction in land value from regulation is treated like a competitive loss requiring no compensation unless all economically viable use is wiped out. The Supreme Court in effect treats regulation and competition as the same for legal purposes, though they have very different economic consequences.Richard Epstein on Property Rights, Zoning and Kelo 9/17/2007
- Epstein's proposed reform is to make diminution in value presumptively compensable, with exceptions only for preventing a bona fide common-law nuisance or controlling a traffic problem, and this rule would need to apply to all land use restrictions, not just formal condemnation orders.Richard Epstein on Property Rights, Zoning and Kelo 9/17/2007
- When a regulation takes value without reaching a common-law nuisance, the compensation should be the full value of the diminution, whereas restrictions that stop a truly noxious use, such as a coke factory in a residential district, can rightly be imposed without compensation.Richard Epstein on Property Rights, Zoning and Kelo 9/17/2007
- Under current doctrine, a regulator can wipe out 80 percent of a $100,000 parcel's value for nothing, but the last 10 percent (from 90 percent down to 100 percent loss) costs $90,000 in compensation, so the political equilibrium stops near 90 percent loss.Richard Epstein on Property Rights, Zoning and Kelo 9/17/2007
- In many zoning cases, the reduction in land value attributable to zoning for improper purposes, without compensation, runs as much as 80 to 90 percent of the value of the land.Richard Epstein on Property Rights, Zoning and Kelo 9/17/2007