determinism
The thesis that the state of the world at one time, together with the laws, fixes the state at all other times.
As defined in ms_215
Where it comes up · 27
- 39 - Free Will Revisited8 claims
- 56 - Abusing Dolores7 claims
- 241 - Final Thoughts On Free Will6 claims
- 10 - Faith Vs. Fact5 claims
- 354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality4 claims
- 80 | Jenann Ismael on Connecting Physics to the World of Experience4 claims
- Alan Lightman on Stardust, Meaning, Religion, and Science2 claims
- 318 - Physics Philosophy2 claims
and 19 more
Most important claims · 10 of 62Search all claims for “determinism” →
- In Spinoza's determinism, the fact that everything is determined does not exclude individual effort because the causal process itself involves and is constituted by our individual efforts; thus determinism and agency are not contradictory but complementary aspects of the same causal chain.A History of Philosophy | 37 Reason and Emotions in Spinoza
- Laplace's demon is a thought experiment of a vast intelligence knowing every particle's position and velocity plus all laws, to which past and future are equally clear, but it crucially does not exist and could never exist; to model the universe it would need to be as complex as the universe itself, so taking it literally as 'a dude who knows a lot of stuff' is deeply misleading.AMA | May 2021
- On the issue of freedom and determinism, Descartes holds that the will is indeterminate and free, thus requiring restraint to prevent it from affirming or denying without proper deliberation; Spinoza is a strict determinist by virtue of inner causal processes; and Leibniz finds freedom and determinism compatible because he conceives freedom not as freedom from mechanical causes but as freedom to pursue goals and actualize one's inner entelechy or nature.A History of Philosophy | 38 Spinoza (continued), Leibniz
- Even if the universe is fully deterministic, one should act as if it is not—captured in Hoffman's 'Quixotic' handle—because acting that way may create a possibility that the system is not all deterministic, raising the open question of whether this is intelligent self-deception or genuine agency.Reid Hoffman
- Free will is not just an illusion we are stuck with but a concept so incoherent that it is impossible to say what would have to be true of the world for it to exist; there is no semblance of anything obscuring what is actually happening, so it isn't even an illusion of anything, because no description of causality—determinism, randomness, or any combination—could cash out the idea of free agency.241 - Final Thoughts On Free Will
- The most challenging objection to compatibilism that does not merely misunderstand the argument is the consequence/manipulation-style worry that if all our actions are fully determined by prior states we did not choose, then the kind of freedom compatibilism preserves may not be the morally significant freedom people actually care about.AMA | April 2025
- Whether the laws of physics are deterministic or indeterministic has nothing to do with free will; the strong libertarian sense of free will concerns whether you can violate the laws of physics by thinking, which Carroll denies, and a universe with indeterministic laws has exactly as much free will as a deterministic one as long as its laws are always obeyed.AMA | December 2020
- Luther's declaration 'I can do no other' shows that responsibility does not require an undetermined choice: Luther is not ducking responsibility but saying he was determined to do this, yet it is still a free decision; it is a crazy fantasy to insist there must have been some earlier absolutely undetermined fork in his childhood for his action to count as responsible.39 - Free Will Revisited
- Whether Laplace's Demon could know for certain what it will do next raises a self-reference problem: a system attempting to fully predict its own future state, including the act of prediction, may face logical limits, so even a perfect predictor of the external universe may not be able to certainly predict its own next action.AMA | March 2025
- To the extent the laws of physics are deterministic, information is conserved from moment to moment, so in a precise sense the entire past is contained in the present moment, which gives quantitative rigor to St. Augustine's claim that the past is present memory; whether all of today's specific information was implicit in the early universe depends on which quantum interpretation (deterministic hidden variables, stochastic collapse, or many-worlds) is correct.AMA | May 2021