descriptive
Pertaining to factual properties of the world (e.g., color, length, quantity) that we can access through independent investigation, as opposed to value-laden normative claims.
As defined in Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard
Where it comes up · 2
- 364 - Facts Values3 claims
- Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard2 claims
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “descriptive” →
- The fact that we may not be motivated by a moral truth—or fail to persuade others—does not suggest that moral truths don't exist; this confuses a prescriptive (should) with a descriptive (can) conception of ethics, since our beliefs about good and evil relate to what is ultimately possible for human beings regardless of our failures of will.364 - Facts Values
- Mimetic theory is commonly misunderstood as crude imitation of actions; in fact Girard is interested in the imitation (or negative imitation) of values--when I see a man date a certain woman, I don't copy his action but absorb the highlighted qualities like slimness that get implanted in me as ideals, which is why the normative-versus-descriptive distinction matters and why mimesis covers behaviors that don't appear imitative on their face.Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard
- Moralizing notions like 'should' and 'ought' are just ways of indicating that certain experiences and states of being are clearly better than others; saying you shouldn't lie is synonymous with the descriptive claim that lying needlessly complicates lives, destroys reputations, and undermines trust, and the prescriptive framing comes largely from the stultifying influence of Abrahamic religion rather than any deep necessity.364 - Facts Values
- Mimetic theory undermines modernity's two answers to where normative certainty comes from: against the Enlightenment's appeal to reason, Girard says reason is often a lawyer and spokesperson for values we have already ingested tribalistically through social needs; against Romanticism's appeal to personal intuition, he notes we desire prestige, the right job, and the right postal code strongly, so the strength of a desire cannot indicate its authenticity.Johnathan Bi on Mimesis and René Girard
- Three distinct projects are easily conflated: (1) a descriptive science of morality studying what people do in the name of morality; (2) understanding how good human life could be and how to maximize well-being; and (3) persuading people committed to harmful things to change—the third being the most important and most difficult, but impossible without first establishing in what sense anyone can be right or wrong about values.364 - Facts Values