defined benefit
A pension system where the employer guarantees a specified retirement benefit based on years of service and salary, regardless of investment performance.
As defined in Joshua Rauh on Public Pensions
Where it comes up · 4
- Joshua Rauh on Public Pensions11 claims
- The CEO Who Cheated Death, Slept an Hour a Night, and Built a Healthcare Empire1 claim
- Alternative Investing: Alts For All1 claim
- Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “defined benefit” →
- The fact that public employees would choose a guaranteed defined benefit over a non-guaranteed pooled defined contribution plan demonstrates that the guarantee is genuinely more valuable and costly—which is precisely why return assumptions that ignore the guarantee are wrong.Joshua Rauh on Public Pensions
- Five or six million public sector employees and retirees are outside the Social Security system entirely because their systems never opted in, leaving them reliant solely on these pensions for retirement income—a frightening exposure given the funding problems.Joshua Rauh on Public Pensions
- Under the current structure the riskiness of the pension promise is borne by taxpayers rather than employees, so employees receive a generous guarantee whose risk is paid for by someone else—a bad set of incentives.Joshua Rauh on Public Pensions
- Because a public sector pension promise is a guarantee paid regardless of market performance, you cannot use the expected returns on risky assets (the 8% historical portfolio return) to value it; the appropriate discount rate is close to the risk-free rate, which proper financial accounting requires.Joshua Rauh on Public Pensions
- Guaranteeing defined-benefit pensions amounts to writing a large insurance policy on the stock market, requiring taxpayers to supply additional money for public employees whenever the market underperforms.Joshua Rauh on Public Pensions
- Unlike Social Security, which Congress has a history of adjusting via technical changes to benefits and contributions, state pension promises are treated as contractual obligations that governors and legislators have repeatedly failed to change, typically backing down to apply reforms only to brand-new employees.Joshua Rauh on Public Pensions
- As long as state and local governments reject proper cost measurement (low discount rates), they should not offer new defined-benefit promises and should move to defined-contribution plans; defined benefit could continue only if they accept that guaranteed deferred promises must be costed at very low discount rates.Joshua Rauh on Public Pensions
- Social Security is not a personal savings account but a defined-benefit welfare program with a large redistributive component; the fiction that you pay into your own account sustains universal support, but means-testing it is resisted precisely because removing the universal illusion would erode political support, leaving an unresolved box.Michael Munger on the Basic Income Guarantee
- Eliminating cost-of-living adjustments can resolve 30-40% of the unfunded liability and provides near-term relief, but it does not fix the underlying problem because as long as defined-benefit systems run with mismeasured promises, the remaining liability keeps growing—it only buys time.Joshua Rauh on Public Pensions
- The pension risk structure is especially dangerous because very bad stock market outcomes arrive exactly when future taxpayers are least able to raise revenue or absorb spending cuts, meaning taxpayers must come up with money to pay public-sector retirements at the worst possible times.Joshua Rauh on Public Pensions