credible commitment
The problem of whether parties can believably promise to abide by a bargain or rule in the future, a standard cause of breakdown in peaceful bargaining.
As defined in Barry Weingast on Law
Where it comes up · 7
- John Nye3 claims
- Christopher Coyne on Exporting Democracy after War 04/07/20081 claim
- Garett Jones on Fisher, Debt, and Deflation1 claim
- Anthony Gill on Religion1 claim
- Barry Weingast on Law1 claim
- What Does "Unbiased" Mean in the Digital World? (with Megan McArdle)1 claim
- Does Market Failure Justify Government Intervention? (with Michael Munger)1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “credible commitment” →
- Low decoupling persists because it provides social benefits as a kind of credible commitment; for example, marriage requires investment in firm-specific human capital, and you secure those investments not by rationally discussing under what circumstances you'd leave, but by having people who instinctively feel such discussion is terrible—the emotional, context-bound hardware in our brains is there for a reason.What Does "Unbiased" Mean in the Digital World? (with Megan McArdle)
- Insulated expert bodies—the Federal Reserve (appointed for fixed terms to make the no-inflation promise credible), the Supreme Court (appointed for life), the FDA, and pilot-licensing systems—are real, recurring examples where placing decisions beyond democratic reach is empirically defensible as an alternative to both markets and politics.Does Market Failure Justify Government Intervention? (with Michael Munger)
- Throughout history, central powers crushed regional powers that grew too strong; Francois I of France, who could only borrow at high interest rates due to credible-commitment problems, lowered his borrowing costs by allying with the city of Paris but then broke those deals and reverted to higher rates because he feared Paris becoming too powerful and a potential hotbed of Reformation opposition.John Nye
- Building a world-class university (or institution) in a country with money but low credibility hinges less on early funding than on the harder later phase of credibility-building: being willing to fire people before tenure and credibly guarantee it after, and—crucially—guaranteeing that policies set by one ruler will be honored by the next, which many countries cannot do.John Nye
- After a rapid revolutionary change in leadership, the rational strategy would be to renegotiate the church-state deal, but whether rulers crush or co-opt a religion depends on whether the church can offer a credible commitment to support the new regime; the Russian Orthodox Church's tight bond to the Czars made Lenin distrust it, so crushing was easier, yet even Stalin reverted to the bargain during WWII to rally nationalism.Anthony Gill on Religion
- Bernanke likely sought a supermajority vote for QE3 because a near-unanimous decision gives credible commitment—it will survive even if a few votes are swapped out under a new President—and building a Fed that can make and keep commitments is so valuable that it is worth accepting somewhat worse policy to achieve it.Garett Jones on Fisher, Debt, and Deflation
- A unique and under-discussed feature of China's reform was that it began outside the biggest commercial centers (Guangdong, Fujian, Shenzhen, Xiamen rather than Beijing and Shanghai), which avoided interfering with established companies' rents, provided plausible deniability if it failed, and exploited ethnic and linguistic ties to Taiwan (Fujianese) and Hong Kong (Cantonese) so that diaspora investors could make informal social deals despite the absence of formal property rights—and crucially, the center failed to shut these growing regions down, breaking the historical pattern of central powers crushing successful regional powers.John Nye
- A credible commitment problem undermines reconstruction: even if rival groups could strike an agreement, they have no reason to believe it is binding once the occupier (the third-party enforcer) eventually exits, so the absence of a credible long-term enforcer discourages cooperative settlement.Christopher Coyne on Exporting Democracy after War 04/07/2008
- Societies with dispersed violence potential struggle to sustain stable rules because adaptive efficiency requires adapting to changing circumstances, and when circumstances change the relative capacities of groups shift; for cooperation to persist each group with violence potential must consider itself better off under peace than violence, which credible-commitment problems and asymmetric information disrupt.Barry Weingast on Law