credentialism
The over-reliance on formal educational qualifications as a requirement for jobs, beyond what the job actually requires.
As defined in Bryan Caplan
Where it comes up · 4
- Tyler Cowen on Stubborn Attachments, Prosperity, and the Good Society2 claims
- Bryan Caplan1 claim
- Tyler Cowen on Talent1 claim
- 395 - Intellectual Authority And Its Discontents1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “credentialism” →
- Mere credentialism is not a perfect filter because a PhD from Caltech more or less guarantees that a person is smart but cannot guarantee they are sane, while it remains genuinely possible for someone outside a field to make important contributions—so edge cases of the lone genius and the credentialed crank must be resolved by getting other real authorities to render judgment.395 - Intellectual Authority And Its Discontents
- Excess credentialism reflects psychologists' 'action bias' — the impulse to do something visible about social problems — leading society to build a big education system and push everyone through it, but the main result is not universal good jobs but employers ratcheting up educational expectations for the same jobs (secretary, bartender).Bryan Caplan
- The reason clustering matters more now than decades ago is that economic growth has concentrated in clustering-intensive sectors—information technology, finance, creative industries—unlike spread-out activities such as cement production, while increased credentialism and globalization further raise the value of being in major cities.Tyler Cowen on Stubborn Attachments, Prosperity, and the Good Society
- Requiring college degrees for many ordinary jobs makes no sense, acts as a barrier to minorities and to women who had children at the wrong time or left school to raise families, and is one of the worst things American society does—a path like Cowen's father's success without a degree is no longer possible today.Tyler Cowen on Talent
- Credentialism has intensified because of more occupational licensing, growth of the certification-heavy service sector, the greater complexity and value of production making employers risk-averse, and a signaling game in which the required credential inches upward each generation from undergraduate to Masters and possibly to PhD without anyone pulling the plug.Tyler Cowen on Stubborn Attachments, Prosperity, and the Good Society