core theory
Carroll's term for the well-established combination of quantum field theory and general relativity (in the weak-field regime) that governs all the physics of everyday life.
As defined in AMA | April 2022
Other definitions
Carroll's term for the combined Standard Model and general relativity that describes all physics relevant to everyday life.
AMA | December 2023
Where it comes up · 25
- AMA | October 20215 claims
- AMA | August 20214 claims
- 245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics3 claims
- 183 | Michael Dine on Supersymmetry, Anthropics, and the Future of Particle Physics2 claims
- 295 | Solo: Emergence and Layers of Reality2 claims
- AMA | April 20222 claims
- AMA | June 20222 claims
- AMA | September 20222 claims
and 17 more
Most important claims · 10 of 39Search all claims for “core theory” →
- The peculiar situation in fundamental physics is that we have a theory that fits all the data, yet almost every working physicist is convinced it is not the final answer or is incomplete, while the data provides no clues for how to move beyond it — a very tough position with no direct experimental guidance.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics
- Quantum field theory's crossing symmetry implies that any particle or field able to affect the matter we are made of could inevitably be produced by colliding that same matter together; since particle accelerators do exactly this and have found nothing relevant, there can be no undiscovered force or particle relevant to everyday human-scale life unless quantum field theory is dramatically wrong, which is the basis of the core-theory claim that everyday life is fully understood.AMA | May 2021
- We cannot know whether physics in 1000 versus 5000 years will be similar or radically different, because scientific progress has no momentum—the fact that we've had revolutions doesn't entail more will come, and we genuinely can't know what's impossible to know; what is certain is both that revolutions remain possible and that we already understand far more about fundamental reality than 500 years ago, with the core theory underlying everyday life completely known.AMA | April 2022
- The laws of physics underlying everyday life are completely known, captured by the Core Theory (quantum field theory of the Standard Model plus gravity as an effective field theory), and this claim is well accepted among physicists who understand effective field theory even if it is rarely stated plainly.AMA | March 2025
- The core theory—general relativity combined with quantum field theory—fully accounts for the matter we engage with in everyday life, including the neurons in our brains, leaving no need for undiscovered energy fields to explain ordinary phenomena.AMA | August 2023
- Whether strong emergence (collective behavior not predictable from simulating lower-level laws) occurs at all depends on what your two levels are: it does not happen when the lower level is simple, local fundamental physics like quantum field theory, but there may be a useful sense in which strong emergence occurs when connecting one complex level of analysis to another complex level, such as a nation emerging from its citizens.AMA | April 2022
- Even if the Core Theory currently covers all everyday human-scale phenomena, future inventions in everyday life might exploit exotic physics (such as captive black holes or wormholes) not currently encountered, so it is uncertain whether the Core Theory of 2025 will continue to cover everyday phenomena over hundreds of years—just as the LHC was a human-scale invention whose behavior was not completely predictable from the Core Theory of its time.AMA | May 2025
- Semi-classical gravity is general relativity quantized but restricted to the weak-field regime; it agrees with all experiments accessible to us, but it is not a step toward solving quantum gravity because all the genuine problems lie in regimes like black hole singularities and the Big Bang where semi-classical gravity does not apply.AMA | March 2022
- While explaining consciousness fully requires biology and neuroscience, the specific question of whether the known laws of physics must be changed to account for conscious experience can legitimately skip biology; Carroll holds the laws of physics are perfectly up to the task and that those who think otherwise vastly underestimate how hard it is to change the laws of physics.AMA | July 2022
- Proponents of non-physical theories of consciousness face a dilemma: either the non-physical component has no effect on the physical world (and is therefore explanatorily idle), or it interacts with the brain in ways that would profoundly violate the well-established laws of physics; there is no comfortable middle ground.AMA | June 2023