continuum hypothesis
Cantor's hypothesis that there is no infinity strictly between the countable infinity of the natural numbers and the uncountable infinity of the real numbers.
As defined in 282 | Joel David Hamkins on Puzzles of Reality and Infinity
Where it comes up · 3
- 282 | Joel David Hamkins on Puzzles of Reality and Infinity6 claims
- Joel David Hamkins3 claims
- Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Grant Sanderson – AI and the future of math2 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “continuum hypothesis” →
- Although Godel hoped large cardinal axioms would settle the continuum hypothesis, Levy and Solovay proved that any standard large cardinal axiom is consistent with forcing extensions in which CH is true or false while the large cardinal retains its nature, so many set-theoretic statements including CH remain independent of all known large cardinals, undercutting the one-road-upward picture.282 | Joel David Hamkins on Puzzles of Reality and Infinity
- Beyond unsolved research problems there are unsolved expository problems: results proven as true but not understood, such as the independence of the continuum hypothesis via forcing, and the gap between proof and explanation is the key distinction.Dwarkesh Patel Podcast - Grant Sanderson – AI and the future of math
- The continuum hypothesis is independent of all known large cardinal axioms—none of them can settle it—even though large cardinal axioms do resolve the CH for progressively more complex hierarchies of definable sets (Borel, projective) given enough large cardinals.Joel David Hamkins
- The developments of set theory over the past half-century are evidence that there is no unique set-theoretic reality; rather there are multiple alternative set-theoretic universes in which fundamental truths differ, so set-theoretic truth has a fundamentally plural character with no singular meaning to fundamental terms.Joel David Hamkins
- Contrary to those who treat the continuum hypothesis as still open, Hamkins argues CH is already settled: even though it is independent of ZFC, it is settled by our deep understanding of how it behaves across the multiverse — we can force it to be true or false, realize it in inner models, and understand all of that, and that understanding is the answer to CH rather than some single truth value.282 | Joel David Hamkins on Puzzles of Reality and Infinity
- Historically, being a Platonist in mathematics implied a unique mathematical universe, but this connection between Platonism and uniqueness has been severed: one can be a realist about mathematical objects while being a pluralist, holding that there are multiple coherent and fully real concepts of set, each giving rise to its own set-theoretic universe with incompatible truths.282 | Joel David Hamkins on Puzzles of Reality and Infinity
- Paul Cohen's method of forcing (1963) provides a powerful tool for building alternative mathematical realities: from any model of set theory one can construct a forcing extension in which the continuum hypothesis is false, complementing Gödel's 1938 constructible universe where CH is true, together establishing CH's independence.Joel David Hamkins
- The 'dream solution' of settling CH by finding a missing axiom that is self-evidently true for sets and decides CH is impossible: because we already understand that worlds where CH is true and worlds where CH is false are both perfectly acceptable set-theoretically, any proposed axiom that settles CH must fail in one of those acceptable universes, and the very fact that an axiom settles CH undermines its claim to be self-evidently true.282 | Joel David Hamkins on Puzzles of Reality and Infinity
- Whereas a monist treats the independence of a question as showing the theory is too weak (pushing toward stronger axioms), the pluralist treats the independence phenomenon itself as evidence for pluralism, because we can already see how, by choosing the right conception of set, we obtain a set-theoretic universe in which the truth value goes one way or the other.282 | Joel David Hamkins on Puzzles of Reality and Infinity
- The continuum hypothesis is the question of whether there is any infinity strictly between the countable infinity of the natural numbers and the uncountable infinity of the real numbers (the continuum); CH asserts there is nothing in between.282 | Joel David Hamkins on Puzzles of Reality and Infinity