causal

Independence Itself Is Evidence for Pluralism

Whereas a monist treats the independence of a question as showing the theory is too weak (pushing toward stronger axioms), the pluralist treats the independence phenomenon itself as evidence for pluralism, because we can already see how, by choosing the right conception of set, we obtain a set-theoretic universe in which the truth value goes one way or the other.

causalpending

Speaker

Joel Hamkins

Evidence Quote

“the pluralist is going to say, well, the independence phenomenon itself is evidence for pluralism because we can already see how it could be that the continuum hypothesis is true or is false.”

Source

282 | Joel David Hamkins on Puzzles of Reality and Infinity— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:16:57 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...