conjunction fallacy
The alleged error of judging a conjunction of two events more probable than one of its components (the Linda problem); Gigerenzer attributes it to language ambiguity.
As defined in Gerd Gigerenzer on Gut Feelings
Other definitions
The cognitive error of judging a combination of conditions as more probable than one condition alone; Liberty uses it to describe how combining topics makes his niche more specific.
Finding Your Favorite Thing
Where it comes up · 6
- 315 | Branden Fitelson on the Logic and Use of Probability3 claims
- Finding Your Favorite Thing2 claims
- Philip E. Tetlock1 claim
- Gerd Gigerenzer on Gut Feelings1 claim
- Matjaž Leonardis - Science, Identity and Probability1 claim
- 216 | John Allen Paulos on Numbers, Narratives, and Numeracy1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “conjunction fallacy” →
- The conjunction fallacy is people judging a conjunction of conditions (e.g., a senator took a bribe AND used it for his sick daughter's operation) as more likely than a single condition (he took a bribe), even though satisfying two or more conditions is always less probable than satisfying one — and the internet worsens this because abundant available factoids let people cobble together superficially plausible but improbable stories.216 | John Allen Paulos on Numbers, Narratives, and Numeracy
- Although most academics pay lip service to Popperian falsifiability and Bayesian probabilism in their epistemological self-concept, how they actually behave when their egos are at stake is quite different, which is why adversarial collaboration — getting opposing camps to jointly test their claims — is extremely rare and hard to pull off.Philip E. Tetlock
- The conjunction fallacy (the Linda problem, where people judge 'bank teller and feminist' more probable than 'bank teller') is not an error of probability reasoning but a consequence of language being polysemous: 'and' has many meanings, and people intelligently infer the intended meaning—the kind of contextual inference that is a hallmark of human intelligence and is hardest to teach a computer.Gerd Gigerenzer on Gut Feelings
- The conjunction fallacy—shown in Kahneman's Linda experiment where people judge 'banker and feminist' more likely than 'banker' alone—demonstrates that people seek explanatory theories that fit the given information rather than the most probable option.Matjaž Leonardis - Science, Identity and Probability
- Each additional topic combined into a writer's mix makes the audience more specific, and although such niches are hard to convert, the people who find them have nowhere else to go, producing very low churn.Finding Your Favorite Thing
- Cases where the two dimensions of argument strength point in opposite directions—high confirmation but low probability (base rate fallacy) or high probability but low confirmation (conjunction fallacy)—are 'mixed cases' that confuse people because asking 'how strong is this argument?' becomes ambiguous, and there is now psychological evidence that manipulating the relevance dimension significantly affects people's probability judgments.315 | Branden Fitelson on the Logic and Use of Probability
- In the Linda problem, although 'bank teller' is necessarily more probable than 'feminist bank teller' (since the conjunction entails the conjunct), under two weak assumptions—the evidence is not positively relevant to her being a bank teller, but is positively relevant to her being a feminist even given that she is a bank teller—the evidence confirms the conjunction more strongly than the conjunct on every confirmation measure, so people sensibly defer to the more objective confirmation dimension.315 | Branden Fitelson on the Logic and Use of Probability
- The alternative explanation that subjects in the Linda problem misread 'bank teller' as 'non-feminist bank teller' has been refuted by psychological research: experiments where people are first taught to infer conjuncts from conjunctions and then bet still show many betting more on the conjunction even after explicitly working through the logical entailment.315 | Branden Fitelson on the Logic and Use of Probability
- Liberty sees himself as very niche because combining many topics, such as Deadwood, nuclear, Soviets, Marines, enterprise software and AI, makes his niche more specific.Finding Your Favorite Thing