causal

Mixed cases explain reasoning fallacies

Cases where the two dimensions of argument strength point in opposite directions—high confirmation but low probability (base rate fallacy) or high probability but low confirmation (conjunction fallacy)—are 'mixed cases' that confuse people because asking 'how strong is this argument?' becomes ambiguous, and there is now psychological evidence that manipulating the relevance dimension significantly affects people's probability judgments.

causalpending

Speaker

Branden Fitelson

Evidence Quote

“it's no surprise they led to the Nobel Prize about concerning how quote unquote, bad people are at probabilistic reasoning. It's because the cases are mixed that people get confused.”

Source

315 | Branden Fitelson on the Logic and Use of Probability— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:14:37 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...