compositionality
The principle that the meaning of a complex expression is determined by the meanings of its constituent parts plus the way they are syntactically combined.
As defined in 230 | Raphaël Millière on How Artificial Intelligence Thinks
Where it comes up · 5
- 15 | David Poeppel on Thought, Language, and How to Understand the Brain2 claims
- 230 | Raphaël Millière on How Artificial Intelligence Thinks2 claims
- Edward Gibson1 claim
- 346 | Erica Cartmill on How Human and Animal Minds Think and Play1 claim
- Gottlob Frege - On Sense and Reference1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “compositionality” →
- The truth value of a declarative sentence (whether it is true or false) is the reference of that sentence, because truth value is the only property that remains invariant under substitution of co-referring terms and satisfies the compositionality constraint.Gottlob Frege - On Sense and Reference
- The dual-stream model of language processing, developed by Hickok and Poeppel, adapts the visual system's division into a 'what' (object identification) and 'where' (localization) pathway, positing one stream that maps sound to meaning (structure and content) and another that maps sound to articulation (motor output), because sub-specialized circuitry optimized for each problem is an efficient engineering solution the brain reuses.15 | David Poeppel on Thought, Language, and How to Understand the Brain
- When you decompose language into specific features—syntax, reference, compositionality—you can find at least one other species that has each individual ability, but no other species possesses all of them together; humans uniquely combine all the pieces, which may make the result qualitatively different even though there is no single switch that distinguishes 'language' from 'no language.'346 | Erica Cartmill on How Human and Animal Minds Think and Play
- The claim that human language is uniquely special (e.g., having compositionality) is not well-supported by evidence, because we cannot yet understand the communication systems of whales, crows, or monkeys; higher species with apparent communicative abilities may have far more signal—possibly something complex like human language—than we assume.Edward Gibson
- Compositionality, as defined by linguist Barbara Partee, is the principle that the meaning of a complex expression (like a sentence) is determined by the meanings of its constituent words together with the way those words are syntactically combined—so 'man bites dog' differs from 'dog bites man' and a sentence is an ordered structure, not a bag of words.230 | Raphaël Millière on How Artificial Intelligence Thinks
- The longstanding objection from symbolic-approach proponents is that connectionist models cannot account for the compositionality of thought because, unlike symbolic systems where discrete representations for 'dog,' 'man,' and 'bites' are co-tokened into a complex expression, connectionist models use distributed sub-symbolic representations that do not neatly decompose into representations of the individual elements.230 | Raphaël Millière on How Artificial Intelligence Thinks
- Poeppel is optimistic that within about ten years the field will get a grip on the elementary operations of composition or combinatorics that put items together into larger units (e.g., understanding that 'red can' is a can, not a red), but he remains deeply puzzled about the more fundamental problem of how the brain stores any information at all, which he considers one of the deepest mysteries of neuroscience.15 | David Poeppel on Thought, Language, and How to Understand the Brain