commodification
Treating something (like a body part or human relationship) as a commercial good that can be bought and sold, which some find morally objectionable.
As defined in Tina Rosenberg on the Kidney Market in Iran
Other definitions
The process by which goods or services become standardized, interchangeable, and price-driven, losing unique value; used here for generic writing that AI can produce cheaply
AI’s New World Order: US-China, War, Job Loss | Tyler Cowen
Where it comes up · 8
- Sally Satel on Organ Donation3 claims
- 353 | Alvin Roth on the Economics of Morally Contested Markets2 claims
- Slavoj Zizek debates Jordan Peterson [HD, Clean Audio, Full]2 claims
- Why the rise of a new cloud-based ruling class is crushing democracy | Yanis Varoufakis2 claims
- Everything You’re Told About The Global Economy Is Wrong | Aaron Bastani Meets Philip Pilkington1 claim
- Tina Rosenberg on the Kidney Market in Iran1 claim
- Branko Milanovic on Capitalism, Alone1 claim
- Michael Munger on Free Markets1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 13Search all claims for “commodification” →
- The moral objection that you shouldn't sell parts of your body is undercut because we already pay people for plasma (enough that the US supplies the world), sperm, and eggs; egg donation in particular raises more fraught ethical issues than kidney donation since it can produce a human being.Tina Rosenberg on the Kidney Market in Iran
- Critics misuse 'coercion': true coercion means either physically forcing someone or presenting a choice where every option leaves them worse off ('your money or your life'), so offering someone the option to sell a kidney is not coercion because declining leaves them no worse off; what critics actually mean is 'undue inducement'--an offer so tempting it interferes with rational cost-benefit weighing--as distinct from ordinary 'inducement' like a store sale that merely prompts a choice you might not otherwise make.Sally Satel on Organ Donation
- Exploitation genuinely applies in the black market, where poor sellers are offered a pittance (e.g. ~$2,000), rarely receive what they were promised, have no contracts, and no informed consent or post-operative care; an ethically sound legal system would instead require respect for the donor's autonomy, informed consent, generous reward, expressed gratitude, and guaranteed health insurance for complications.Sally Satel on Organ Donation
- It is inconsistent that surgeons, nephrologists, and Organ Procurement Organizations all receive cash (e.g. ~$50,000 to procure and transfer a deceased organ) for transplantation, yet the one person who takes the real risk and gives the thing of value--the donor--is forbidden from being rewarded; the surgeon's paid service is itself a form of commodification that no one objects to.Sally Satel on Organ Donation
- Objections to morally contested markets fall into at least three distinct types: that the thing traded is intrinsically ethically wrong (e.g. killing), that the market would be exploitative of the sellers, and that it commoditizes people in a way we reject even if everyone is made better off—with the third sounding most like mere paternalism.353 | Alvin Roth on the Economics of Morally Contested Markets
- In Mad Men, Don Draper teaches Peggy that a Hershey bar is not purchased for chocolate but for recapturing the emotion of parental love, exemplifying the commodification of nostalgiaWhy the rise of a new cloud-based ruling class is crushing democracy | Yanis Varoufakis
- Advertisers used access to captured audience attention to commodify emotions that had previously escaped commodification, deepening overall commodification of human experienceWhy the rise of a new cloud-based ruling class is crushing democracy | Yanis Varoufakis
- Pilkington wrote an article for National Interest (a DC geopolitics publication) arguing that the commodification process is happening in the weapons market—that new weapon systems are being built from consumer technology (which is then weaponized) rather than military tech filtering down to consumers, representing a reversal of the historical pattern with massive strategic implications for who can wage war.Everything You’re Told About The Global Economy Is Wrong | Aaron Bastani Meets Philip Pilkington
- There are broadly two objections to paying for kidneys: first, that buying or selling body parts is simply wrong because it commoditizes people; second, the more nuanced concern that only poor people would sell and would be coerced into it, turning an altruistic life-saving act into something exploitative that corrupts the medical profession.353 | Alvin Roth on the Economics of Morally Contested Markets
- It is capitalism itself, not some external cultural Marxist conspiracy, that causes the commodification of culture and the erosion of traditional moral values, as Daniel Bell documented in 'The Cultural Contradictions of Capitalism'.Slavoj Zizek debates Jordan Peterson [HD, Clean Audio, Full]