club goods
Goods that are excludable but non-rival, where benefits flow mainly to members of a group; here used to note that much 'charity' is really member-benefiting consumption.
As defined in Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System
Where it comes up · 4
- A Practical Guide to Controlling Addiction & Dopamine | Dr. Anna Lembke | Knowledge Project 1592 claims
- Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System2 claims
- Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/20081 claim
- Michael Munger on Constitutions1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “club goods” →
- James Buchanan won the Nobel Prize in large part for his work on clubs: club goods are excludable but non-rival (a pool doesn't get crowded until many people use it), so collectively citizens can privately create public goods like tennis courts and pools through voluntary associations governed by small-c constitutions you consent to, can be expelled from, or can quit.Michael Munger on Constitutions
- AA has many ritualistic elements—meetings, prescribed introductions ('My name is... and I'm an alcoholic'), standardized storytelling narratives, chip ceremonies, steps, sponsors—that create club goods and community identity, which are intangible benefits that derive from membership.A Practical Guide to Controlling Addiction & Dopamine | Dr. Anna Lembke | Knowledge Project 159
- By interposing itself between citizens and providing welfare and services, government removes individuals' sense of accountability and obligation to contribute to the larger community, dulling the natural cooperative instinct that arises when people understand their survival depends on others.Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System
- The people's romance actively crowds out, subverts and is jealous of more meaningful local 'club romances'—voluntary club coordination of sentiment (Buchanan-style club goods) such as homeschooling, private schooling, churches and private concentrations of wealth—sometimes working against them almost deliberately, as seen in antagonism toward Walmart.Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008
- In AA, when people relapse, they are not kicked out or shunned but become valuable members by declaring themselves as newcomers and receiving extra support to re-enter recovery, exemplifying the club good of mutual aid.A Practical Guide to Controlling Addiction & Dopamine | Dr. Anna Lembke | Knowledge Project 159
- The welfare state is good at coercively transferring money but not at creating meaningful lives for either those taxed or those receiving benefits, whereas in a different world individuals would have incentives to cooperatively join with others to help, an outlet for an essential part of human nature that government provision removes.Paul Robinson on Cooperation, Punishment and the Criminal Justice System