closed timelike curves
Paths through spacetime that loop back on themselves, allowing travel into one's own past; their possibility is treated as the empirical benchmark distinguishing eternalism from presentism.
As defined in 140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain
Where it comes up · 7
- 24 | Kip Thorne on Gravitational Waves, Time Travel, and Interstellar3 claims
- 140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain1 claim
- 155 | Stephen Wolfram on Computation, Hypergraphs, and Fundamental Physics1 claim
- 316 | Niayesh Afshordi and Phil Halper1 claim
- AMA | February 20221 claim
- AMA | May 20211 claim
- Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | July 20261 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “closed timelike curves” →
- The benchmark distinction between presentism and eternalism is the possibility of time travel via closed timelike curves—for presentists these are off the table because you cannot travel to a past that no longer exists—so constructing closed timelike curves would empirically settle the debate in favor of eternalism.140 | Dean Buonomano on Time, Reality, and the Brain
- Lee Smolin's cosmological natural selection proposes that black holes give birth to new universes whose daughters have slightly different physical constants, creating a Darwinian selection pressure favoring universes that produce more black holes—offering a solution to the fine-tuning problem with no intelligent designer required.316 | Niayesh Afshordi and Phil Halper
- The existence of closed timelike curve solutions to Einstein's well-tested equations does not give high credence to eternalism in the way many-worlds branching does, because branching is predicted to actually happen in our universe whenever quantum systems entangle, whereas CTC solutions that are not our universe (Tipler cylinders, Gödel universe, wormholes) provide no argument against presentism as long as they are not realized in our actual spacetime.AMA | May 2021
- Carroll's sharpest 'aha' moment came on a plane ride home from a seminar: learning from Don Page that the Lorentz group in 2+1 dimensions has the geometry of anti-de Sitter space let him prove via simple geometric arguments that you cannot build a time machine (closed timelike curves) without starting with one—illustrating how a single provocative fact can unlock a problem he and collaborators had struggled with.AMA | February 2022
- In Polchinski's Paradox—a billiard ball sent into a wormhole time machine emerges in time to knock itself off course and prevent its own entry—nature avoids the contradiction not by sacrificing logical consistency but by sacrificing predictability: the ball receives a gentle self-collision that slightly alters its trajectory, and there turn out to be multiple classical solutions where previously it seemed there were none.24 | Kip Thorne on Gravitational Waves, Time Travel, and Interstellar
- Quantum mechanics can be formulated in the presence of a time machine using the Feynman sum-over-histories approach generalized by Gell-Mann and Hartle, and doing so probably yields a single unique consistent solution from the multiple classical possibilities; this is not about branching into parallel timelines but about finding the one most probable trajectory that actually happens.24 | Kip Thorne on Gravitational Waves, Time Travel, and Interstellar
- Asks whether macro-scale closed timelike loops, such as Terminator-style agents from the future creating their own predecessors, are essentially a modern form of self-fulfilling prophecy.Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | July 2026
- Once quantum mechanics is properly formulated in the presence of a time machine (closed timelike curves), one discovers that information gets lost—a conclusion most physicists dislike but which Thorne finds wonderful, leading into the information loss paradox where he holds an iconoclastic minority view.24 | Kip Thorne on Gravitational Waves, Time Travel, and Interstellar
- Getting a perfect harmonic oscillator in these models requires closed timelike curves (the history of the universe repeating itself), which is a weird idealization; real physics probably has no perfect harmonic oscillators, illustrating that insisting on standard idealizations stresses the model just as deriving perfect rigid-body mechanics stresses molecular dynamics.155 | Stephen Wolfram on Computation, Hypergraphs, and Fundamental Physics