cigar butt
An investment strategy of buying deeply discounted, low-quality companies (like finding a discarded cigar with one good puff left)—extracting short-term value from beaten-down securities with minimal expected future growth
As defined in Charlie Munger in Conversation with Todd Combs | Singleton Prize for CEO Excellence
Where it comes up · 7
- Value Investing Fundamentals & Current Market Conditions w/ John Huber (TIP634)2 claims
- Cultivating a Disaster Resistant, Compound Interest Machine2 claims
- Charlie Munger in Conversation with Todd Combs | Singleton Prize for CEO Excellence1 claim
- The Moat Portfolio1 claim
- The Berkshire of Software1 claim
- Jeremy Giffon - Special Situations in Private Markets - [Invest Like the Best, Replay]1 claim
- Adam Karr: Know Yourself, Pick Your Game, Build Your Blueprint (Lessons from a Janitor & Investing)1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “cigar butt” →
- Warren Buffett adapted his investment strategy multiple times across his career—from cigar butts to more frequent trading to buy-and-hold—driven by the need to adapt to increasing capital size and changing market environments, not by changing underlying principles.Adam Karr: Know Yourself, Pick Your Game, Build Your Blueprint (Lessons from a Janitor & Investing)
- Huber categorizes investments into three types: Compounders (high-quality, durable businesses with excellent capital allocation and Returns on Capital, regardless of growth rate); Unpopular Large-Caps (the largest stocks in the market that become significantly mispriced at times, often when market sentiment is negative); and Bargains (stocks trading below intrinsic value with strong balance sheets, good cash flow, and margin of safety).Value Investing Fundamentals & Current Market Conditions w/ John Huber (TIP634)
- Buffett's business partnership structure in the 1950s demonstrated the value of having different categories of investments (compounders, workouts, cigar butts) and being flexible, which Huber has adapted to his own fund structure with similar diversification across investment types while maintaining his circle of competence.Value Investing Fundamentals & Current Market Conditions w/ John Huber (TIP634)
- The transition from cigar-butt investing to compounder investing—buying great companies at reasonable prices and holding long-term—is where the easiest and biggest money can be made, but it's extremely difficult to do because great companies get priced too high by everyone chasing themCharlie Munger in Conversation with Todd Combs | Singleton Prize for CEO Excellence
- Most businesses under 5 million dollars, and many under 10 million, of owner earnings carry so much hidden debt and risk that a Monte Carlo simulation would likely show little expected return, so the firm's edge is buying cigar butts at cigar-butt prices.Cultivating a Disaster Resistant, Compound Interest Machine
- Cigar-butt investments are acceptable, but a new investment should be so compelling that it makes the investor feel compelled to act, since most businesses should be the last business bought; this is a form of laziness that prevents bad deals.Jeremy Giffon - Special Situations in Private Markets - [Invest Like the Best, Replay]
- Constellation Software's advantage is extreme acquisition discipline: a process-driven buyer that will walk away over a few cents, buying maintenance-revenue software companies, pushing margins to around 40%, and reinvesting cash flow into the next acquisition.The Berkshire of Software
- The growth-versus-value classification is not useful to the firm because it does not focus on classic low P/E, low P/B value stocks. But the framework is valuable for investors generally because a business must be analyzed in the context of its economics: a DCF on a no-terminal-value cigar butt is asinine, and dismissing Amazon for a high P/E while it reinvests every dollar at high returns is equally insane.The Moat Portfolio
- In earlier years the speaker followed a Ben Graham style of private investing and was unwilling to overpay, but later recognized the value of Munger-style quality investing.Cultivating a Disaster Resistant, Compound Interest Machine