cage-free
An egg production system where hens roam freely inside a large barn rather than being kept in cages, allowing natural behaviors but with downsides like higher mortality and dust.
As defined in Jayson Lusk on Food, Technology, and Unnaturally Delicious
Where it comes up · 4
- Artificial meat is harder than artificial intelligence — Lewis Bollard6 claims
- Jayson Lusk on Food, Technology, and Unnaturally Delicious2 claims
- Tamar Haspel on Food Costs, Animal Welfare, and the Honey Bee1 claim
- 351 | Peter Singer on Maximizing Good for All Sentient Creatures1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “cage-free” →
- Advocates secured cage-free pledges from almost all the largest food companies globally by capturing the divide between what consumers already assumed was happening and what was actually happening with battery cages, which the industry did not disclose; this transition has already spared over 200 million hens a year, taking the US from under 10% to 47% cage-free and the EU to 62%.Artificial meat is harder than artificial intelligence — Lewis Bollard
- The enriched or colony cage, developed by European researchers and adopted by companies like J.S. West, is an innovative compromise between battery cages and cage-free systems: a king-mattress-sized cage holding 50-60 birds with perches, dust-bathing areas, and private nesting areas, providing more freedom of movement and natural behaviors while avoiding the severe pecking and dust problems of open barns, at a cost between the two systems.Jayson Lusk on Food, Technology, and Unnaturally Delicious
- Cage-free eggs cost only about 19 cents more per dozen to produce but retailers like Walmart and Kroger charge roughly $1 to $2 more, using welfare labels as a price-differentiation tool to extract markups from less price-sensitive wealthier consumers; once cage-free becomes the commodity baseline (as at Costco or in states banning caged eggs), the margins are competed away.Artificial meat is harder than artificial intelligence — Lewis Bollard
- There have been three large-scale drivers of animal welfare progress: government policy (e.g. EU welfare standards affecting billions of animals), corporate reforms (e.g. McDonald's cage-free pledge sparing seven million hens a year in its supply chain), and technology (e.g. in-ovo sexing sparing 200 million chicks).Artificial meat is harder than artificial intelligence — Lewis Bollard
- There is a large gap between consumer perception and reality of welfare-friendly animal products: in the US only two in every thousand chickens (0.2%) are not in factory farms, yet far more than 10% of chicken-eating Americans claim to eat only free-range, and cage-free labeling does not mean free-range since birds may still be confined by the thousands in a shed.351 | Peter Singer on Maximizing Good for All Sentient Creatures
- The egg industry claims it cannot afford the cage-free transition yet has made insane profits during high egg prices—Cal-Maine's share price doubled—because the price elasticity for eggs is very inelastic, allowing producers to crank up prices on even a small supply reduction and capture all the surplus, proving the industries are flush with cash and that willingness, not money, is the constraint on reform.Artificial meat is harder than artificial intelligence — Lewis Bollard
- Although companies pressured egg producers toward cage-free and supply has grown, there is a glut of cage-free eggs because consumers won't pay the roughly $1/dozen premium; consumers see cage-free as not much different from ordinary eggs, so expecting consumers to voluntarily pay more for animal welfare or sustainability is whistling past a graveyard.Tamar Haspel on Food Costs, Animal Welfare, and the Honey Bee
- Large companies don't loudly advertise cage-free improvements because consumers already assumed they weren't using caged eggs, so advertising the change would reveal they previously used caged eggs and that phase-ins mean continued caged-egg use for years; this dissonance between perceived and actual practice means merely removing the worst practices is insufficient to create an advertising claim.Artificial meat is harder than artificial intelligence — Lewis Bollard
- Cage-free and free-range systems have real downsides that contradict the romantic ideal: they tend to have higher hen mortality rates because chickens that don't know each other establish a pecking order and peck each other, and the open barns are dirty and dusty environments that harm both the chickens' and workers' health.Jayson Lusk on Food, Technology, and Unnaturally Delicious
- The dollar-to-suffering ratio in this space is extraordinary: corporate reforms cost less than $100 million a year over a couple of years and benefit hundreds of millions to billions of animals, yielding a ratio far better than $1 per 10 years of improved animal wellbeing—an opportunity that exists precisely because the area is systematically neglected.Artificial meat is harder than artificial intelligence — Lewis Bollard