Tamar Haspel on Food Costs, Animal Welfare, and the Honey Bee
What this covers
Tamar Haspel, a Washington Post food columnist, discusses the economics and production of food with Russ Roberts, examining why certain foods cost what they do and what that reveals about agricultural systems. Rather than blame subsidies or corporate greed for cheap processed food, Haspel argues that the price gap between row crops and vegetables stems from crop biology and mechanization—a tomato harvester invented at UC Davis in the 1960s, for instance, cut labor costs for canning by 92%. The conversation ranges across how post-war labor shortages drove farmers toward expensive capital investments like combines, which in turn forced consolidation into larger operations; how modern egg production achieves staggering efficiency through automation; and why blind taste tests reveal that backyard eggs taste indistinguishable from store-bought ones, their perceived superiority coming entirely from visual and contextual cues.
The discussion turns to harder questions about trade-offs and change. Haspel notes that while consumers claim to want cage-free and sustainable food, they won't pay premiums—a gap between stated values and actual purchasing behavior rooted in revealed preference. This means producers, not consumers, must drive change. The conversation touches on externalities like fertilizer runoff causing dead zones in waterways, the varroa mite as the primary threat to honey bees, and a provocative reframing of global nutrition: whole grains and legumes, not green vegetables, are the uncharismatic but efficient crops capable of feeding a growing world. Haspel also raises the moral question of whether cheap food justifies confining animals to tight spaces, and warns that treating food as a status symbol risks deepening inequality when lower-income households struggle with food costs as a daily practical problem.
Haspel argues that the price and production of food are driven mostly by inherent crop characteristics and technology rather than subsidies, and that improving the food system requires recognizing that consumers won't pay for animal welfare or sustainability, so change must come from the food chain itself and from reconnecting people to where food comes from.
- Mechanization (tomato harvesters, combines) and crop biology, not subsidies, explain why row crops are cheap and vegetables expensive
- Consumers say they want cage-free/sustainable food but won't pay premiums, so producers and food companies, not consumers, must drive change
- Whole grains and legumes, not green vegetables, are the efficient nutritious crops capable of feeding the world
Mechanization and capital economics, not subsidies, drive cheap industrial food production.
- Because a combine is extremely expensive, a farmer who buys one not only can farm more acreage but effectively must, in order to achieve the economies of scale needed to justify the capital, which—combined with the flat uniform Midwest geography—drove the consolidation into huge corn, soy, and wheat operations.
“a farmer would get a combine, and all of a sudden, that farmer not just could farm more acreage, but at some level would have to to get the economies of scale to put the capital into the farm equipment.”
- The simultaneous invention at UC Davis of both a mechanical tomato harvester and a harvestable tomato variety in the 1960s, refined over successive machine iterations, dropped the labor cost for canning tomatoes by 92%, which is a major reason canned tomatoes are far cheaper than fresh.
“an engineer at UC Davis invented a tomato harvester at the same time that a plant scientist at UC Davis invented a kind of tomato that was harvestable... the cost of labor for tomatoes dropped 92%. Which is astonishing.”
- The reason processed/industrial foods are cheap and fruits and vegetables are expensive is mostly due to factors inherent to the crops themselves—like mechanizability—rather than government subsidies, which play a real but smaller role.
“subsidies usually are fingered; and I've written about that as well. And they do play a role. But a much bigger role is played by other things that are more inherent to the crops, and aren't, you know, sort of government-imposed. And machines are one of them.”
- After World War II, farm labor moved to cities for better-paying factory jobs, so farmers lost access to their earlier labor pool, and lacking cheap labor is one of the main factors that drives mechanization—coinciding with the shift from tractors to combines.
“after the War, the Second World War, a lot of farm labor moved into cities... not having access to keep labor is one of the factors that really drives mechanization.”
Consumers cannot and will not pay premiums for animal welfare or sustainability improvements.
- The reason the egg industry won't revert to cages is not that consumers will step up to pay more, but that the food chain itself—the large companies that buy raw ingredients—will fix the problem; consumers voting with their wallets won't drive the change.
“the reason we're not going to go back is not because consumers are going to step up. The reason we are not going to go back is that the food chain is going to fix this problem.”
- Even though cage confinement produces high-quality food very cheaply, there has to be a point at which we ask whether we are willing to subject an animal to that treatment in service of a small price differential—and we don't ask that question often enough or rigorously enough.
“there has to be a point at which we say, 'Are we willing to do this to an animal in service of this price differential in eggs?' And I don't think that we ask that question often enough, or rigorously enough.”
- Although companies pressured egg producers toward cage-free and supply has grown, there is a glut of cage-free eggs because consumers won't pay the roughly $1/dozen premium; consumers see cage-free as not much different from ordinary eggs, so expecting consumers to voluntarily pay more for animal welfare or sustainability is whistling past a graveyard.
“Business Insider just did a story last week about how there is a glut of them, and consumers won't buy them because they are unwilling to pay for them.”
- Food taboos, farm-to-table obsessions, and judging people by how they eat are largely phenomena of wealthy people; in lower-income households food is a daily struggle of time and money, so the rise of food as a status sport may represent a further polarization in an already polarized society.
“food taboos and obsessions with how food is made, and you know, the whole farm-to-table movement and things--these are pretty much unique to wealthy people.”
Agricultural problems stem from crop-specific biophysics and systemic pest pressures, not diet composition.
- Eating more green vegetables won't solve agricultural problems because vegetables occupy only about 1% of US cropland and even tripling consumption would use only a small sliver of land; moreover vegetables are inefficient and expensive to grow, delivering far fewer calories per acre than row crops.
“Right now, about 1% of American cropland is planted with vegetables. If we all ate the vegetables that we were supposed to eat, we'd triple or quadruple consumption.”
- Bee health collapse is not from a single cause but a perfect storm: varroa mites, the overall burden of many pesticides (not just neonicotinoids), new viruses, fungi and pathogens, and bee monoculture from a narrow genetic base—and the neonicotinoid problem is driven more by the pesticide cloud released at planting than by the low systemic levels in the plant.
“it's a perfect storm of things that are killing these bees.”
- Once you move from animals to plants, the single biggest agricultural problem is fertilizer runoff, which causes toxic algae blooms that do tremendous harm to water systems, evidenced by large dead zones and disputes in Des Moines, Toledo/Lake Erie, the Neuse River Basin, and the Gulf of Mexico.
“the single biggest problem is fertilizer runoff, because it's causing toxic algae blooms that are doing tremendous harm to water systems.”
- There is a reasonable scientific consensus that the number one problem for honey bee colony losses is the varroa mite—a large parasite (proportionally like a football-sized parasite on a human) introduced around the late 1980s/early 1990s, now in every hive, that both harms bees directly and makes them susceptible to pathogens; better varroa management is improving bee survival.
“there's a reasonable consensus in the scientific beekeeping world that the number one problem is this little, you might call the varroa mite.”
- Commercial beekeepers lose over 30% of their hives every single year, a demoralizing figure that, despite progress in varroa management, shows the numbers remain discouraging.
“for beekeepers to lose over 30% of their hives every single year is really demoralizing.”
Transparency about food production and personal connection to sourcing enable more constructive ethical engagement.
- The way animals are treated in conventional systems is often substandard; even as a meat-eater, the moral position is that if we are going to raise animals for meat we owe them a decent life, which is why Haspel sources most of her meat from hunting, fishing, and her own raised animals.
“I am not a vegetarian. I eat meat. But I believe that if we're going to raise animals for meat, we owe them a decent life.”
- Modern consumers are insulated from how food is produced because most production happens out of public view, which breeds apathy and risks the excesses (animal suffering, exploited farm workers, soil degradation); staying connected to where food comes from could enable society to tackle these problems more constructively.
“when we aren't aware of those things and most food production happens sort of out of public view, that's when we risk some of the excesses”
- A slaughterhouse should be a senior-class trip in every American public high school so that people understand an animal has to die for them to eat meat; whether this changes views permanently or just temporarily deters teenagers from hamburgers is uncertain, but there's no clear downside to the transparency.
“I think that a slaughterhouse should be a Senior Class trip in every public high school in America. I think that it's important to understand that an animal has to die for you to eat meat.”
- There is a compelling, brainstem-level human imperative to feed ourselves, such that producing food by one's own hands provides a deep-seated satisfaction that differs in kind from achievements like acing a test, getting a promotion, or writing a book.
“there is a kind of brainstem-level satisfaction that's different from, you know, acing a test or getting a promotion or writing a book.”
Calorie-rich crops like legumes and grains, not vegetables, should anchor food policy and nutrition thinking.
- There is little mainstream support for a paleo diet being optimal, and from an environmental standpoint a beef-and-leaf diet is the worst you can do in terms of carbon footprint.
“from an environmental standpoint, a beef-and-leaf diet is absolutely the worst you can do in terms of carbon footprint.”
- Green vegetables deliver nutrients with very few calories, while legumes and whole grains deliver nutrients along with calories; from a land-use and global-feeding standpoint you want both nutrients and calories, even though in calorie-rich societies people may prefer the nutrients-without-calories of vegetables.
“broccoli, and green vegetables, deliver essentially nutrients with very few calories. Whereas, legumes and whole grains deliver nutrients with calories. And, given the choice, from a land use point of view you want the nutrients and the calories.”
- Container shipping (and the humble cardboard box) is one of the greatest and most transformative innovations of the 20th century because it dramatically reduced transport costs, even though people more often cite the computer.
“everybody is like, 'Oh, the computer.' And I go with 'Container shipping' every time.”
- Instead of associating 'healthy' with fruits and green vegetables, people should think of whole grains and legumes—lentils, peanuts, dry beans, barley, oats, and even corn and soy eaten as food—because these uncharismatic, dirt-cheap crops deliver nutrients along with the calories the growing world population needs.
“when people think healthy, I wish that I could get them to stop thinking fruits and vegetables and start thinking whole grains and legumes. Because I think those are the answer.”
Perceived food quality differences reflect psychology and knowledge, not objective sensory superiority.
- Egg prices fell because chickens were bred to be highly efficient egg layers that convert feed to eggs on less input, and were raised in increasingly confined cage systems where they expend little energy, producing close to an egg a day—roughly five times the output of a poorly-fed backyard or developing-world chicken.
“we've bred more efficient chickens. And we have also developed systems to raise those chickens more efficiently... you raise the chicken in a smaller and smaller space... It just sits in its cage and it lays eggs.”
- In a blind taste test where people are blindfolded (or color cues are removed), they cannot distinguish backyard eggs from ordinary store eggs; the perceived superiority comes from visual cues and the knowledge of where the egg came from, because we evaluate food on more than flavor—and the chicken is a 'great equalizer' that produces similar eggs across varied diets.
“we discovered that when people are blindfolded, they cannot tell one egg from another.”
- Unlike eggs, honey genuinely varies in flavor and color depending on which flowers the bees harvest—chestnut and buckwheat honeys are dark and distinct, clover honey is light and delicate—so a neighbor's local honey reflects the particular combination of neighborhood flowers, though psychological factors also enhance the appeal.
“honey--it is totally dependent on what those bees are harvesting... they vary depending on the flower, because different nectar tastes different.”