bullshit
In Frankfurt's sense, speech produced by someone who has no concern at all with whether what they say is true or false—distinct from lying, which involves knowingly asserting falsehoods to deceive.
As defined in 61 | Quassim Cassam on Intellectual Vices and What to Do About Them
Where it comes up · 6
- 317 - What Do We Know About Our Minds3 claims
- 108 | Carl Bergstrom on Information, Disinformation, and Bullshit2 claims
- Ep. 1 - Awakening from the Meaning Crisis - Introduction1 claim
- 185 - A Conversation With Paul Bloom1 claim
- 118 - The View From Trumpistan1 claim
- 61 | Quassim Cassam on Intellectual Vices and What to Do About Them1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “bullshit” →
- Using Harry Frankfurt's distinction, Trump is best understood as a bullshitter rather than a liar: a liar reality-tests his statements to make them pass as truths within his audience's logical expectations, whereas a bullshitter expends no cognitive overhead on truth, simply confabulating and leaving the world to react—which explains why Trump's brazenly false claims don't function like normal lies.118 - The View From Trumpistan
- Harry Frankfurt's distinction holds that a liar is fully aware of reality and the audience's expectations and carefully engineers departures from truth to go undetected, whereas a bullshitter is simply indifferent to truth—spending no cognitive overhead tracking reality—and merely creates a mood by bloviating; Trump is a bullshitter to an unsurpassed degree, anchoring to accidental utterances and confabulating to fit them like completing an extemporaneous rhyme.185 - A Conversation With Paul Bloom
- Bullshit is distinct from lying: the liar knows the truth and deliberately leads you away from it, whereas the bullshitter doesn't care what the truth is at all—they use language, figures, or statistical arguments to impress, persuade, or intimidate with blatant disregard for whether the arguments are actually true.108 | Carl Bergstrom on Information, Disinformation, and Bullshit
- A liar must track and respect the truth in order to insert a calculated lie undetectably — observing all logical norms, avoiding self-contradiction, and conserving data — whereas a bullshitter is just creating a mood with no concern for tracking truth or avoiding contradiction, making bullshit a form of complete epistemological anarchy with no standards or ground truth.317 - What Do We Know About Our Minds
- There is an increasing prevalence of BS (bullshit, in Frankfurt's technical sense) pervading culture, society, and academia, which has spiked in concordance with other increases in dark cultural factors.Ep. 1 - Awakening from the Meaning Crisis - Introduction
- Drawing on Harry Frankfurt's distinction, a bullshitter (unlike a liar) simply has no concern for whether what he says is true; in recent politics making false and unfounded claims has shifted from being a fatal defect to being politically acceptable and even effective, and the underlying indifference to truth is itself a powerful and increasingly common intellectual vice.61 | Quassim Cassam on Intellectual Vices and What to Do About Them
- Trump is a bullshitter rather than a liar — he has utter disinterest in truth and will say whatever works for him whether true or false, which is more epistemologically dangerous than lying because a bullshitter, unlike a liar, does not track or respect the truth at all, and this ethos of not caring whether something is true has spread, creating a genuine epistemological crisis.317 - What Do We Know About Our Minds
- Debate is asymmetrical epistemological warfare in which one side can make a mess far faster than the opponent can clean it up — so while almost everyone deserves the right to say what they want, not everyone deserves to be debated, because a bullshitter like a Holocaust denier or Alex Jones can spray ten unfalsifiable claims in thirty seconds that each take a day and a half to fact-check, making real-time refutation impossible.317 - What Do We Know About Our Minds
- The world is awash in bullshit and we are drowning in it.108 | Carl Bergstrom on Information, Disinformation, and Bullshit