broken-windows policing
A policing approach that aggressively pursues minor nuisance offenses (e.g., loitering, public urination) on the theory that doing so prevents larger crime; in practice it generates many low-level police interactions concentrated among the poor.
As defined in Cathy O'Neil on Weapons of Math Destruction
Where it comes up · 2
- Rachel Harmon1 claim
- Cathy O'Neil on Weapons of Math Destruction1 claim
Most important claims · 2 of 2Search all claims for “broken-windows policing” →
- Recidivism risk scores are built on biased data: police interactions are concentrated in poor and minority neighborhoods (per the Ferguson, Baltimore, and Chicago reports), so the arrest data is skewed; and questionnaire items like 'Did you come from a high-crime neighborhood?' or 'Have family members had police interactions?' are direct proxies for race and class—questions that would be unconstitutional in open court but get through because they are embedded in a 'mathematical' system perceived as objective.Cathy O'Neil on Weapons of Math Destruction
- Proactive 'stop, question, and frisk' and broken-windows policing probably did not drive New York's murder-rate decline, because cities that didn't adopt those strategies also saw substantially lower crime and murder rates today; policing had some effect, but stop-question-frisk as carried out in New York was so vastly costly that its benefits must be weighed very cautiously.Rachel Harmon