causal

Recidivism Data Reflects Biased Policing

Recidivism risk scores are built on biased data: police interactions are concentrated in poor and minority neighborhoods (per the Ferguson, Baltimore, and Chicago reports), so the arrest data is skewed; and questionnaire items like 'Did you come from a high-crime neighborhood?' or 'Have family members had police interactions?' are direct proxies for race and class—questions that would be unconstitutional in open court but get through because they are embedded in a 'mathematical' system perceived as objective.

causalpending

Speaker

Cathy O'Neil

Evidence Quote

“if a lawyer said, 'Oh, this person's father was in jail, Judge, so please sentence this person for longer.' That would not fly. But because it's embedded in this scoring system, it somehow gets through. And the reason it gets through is because it's mathematical.”

Source

Cathy O'Neil on Weapons of Math Destruction— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:25:42 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...