black market
An illegal, unregulated market for buying and selling goods (here kidneys), typically involving brokers, exploitation, and inadequate medical care.
As defined in Tina Rosenberg on the Kidney Market in Iran
Other definitions
Illegal or unregulated market for goods and services, operating outside official state oversight; in context of sanctions, trade that violates restrictions and uses alternative payment/shipping methods to bypass enforcement
Ben Rhodes: The Warren and Anita Manshel Lecture in American Foreign Policy
Where it comes up · 9
- Tina Rosenberg on the Kidney Market in Iran4 claims
- 353 | Alvin Roth on the Economics of Morally Contested Markets3 claims
- Ben Rhodes: The Warren and Anita Manshel Lecture in American Foreign Policy2 claims
- #386: Akio Morita: Founder of Sony2 claims
- Larry White on the Clash of Economic Ideas1 claim
- Michael Munger on John Locke, Prices, and Hurricane Sandy1 claim
- Peter Boettke on Katrina, Ten Years After1 claim
- Ask Me Anything 111 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 16Search all claims for “black market” →
- For markets to work well they need social support, but so do bans on markets; banning something does not make it vanish, which is why it is easy to buy drugs but hard to hire a hitman even though the laws against both are nearly identical—society treats hitman solicitation with alarm and cooperates to entrap it, while drug purchasing meets little social resistance.353 | Alvin Roth on the Economics of Morally Contested Markets
- Alcohol prohibition in the 1920s-30s failed to prevent the harms prohibitionists feared—drunk driving, family damage, deaths—because there was abundant alcohol and crime anyway; the clear result of returning to a legal market is that you can no longer buy moonshine from gangsters, who were outcompeted by legal suppliers, suggesting legalization's main reliable effect is displacing criminal markets rather than eliminating the underlying harms.353 | Alvin Roth on the Economics of Morally Contested Markets
- Hayek's Road to Serfdom is a warning rather than a prediction: if, when central planning fails, planners try harder—eliminating black markets and jailing critics rather than stepping back—then civil liberties become endangered and society heads toward serfdom, but this path can always be avoided by mending one's ways.Larry White on the Clash of Economic Ideas
- The market value of a kidney differs between an illegal regime and a legal/encouraged one because both the number of donors and recipients change—more people donate when it feels safe and paid, and more recipients use the system when comfortable—so the eventual market price in a legal system is genuinely hard to predict.Tina Rosenberg on the Kidney Market in Iran
- For-profit brokers may be exploitative specifically in illegal markets because brand name and reputation cannot easily operate under-the-table, whereas in an open legal market reputation disciplines providers (a grocery that cuts corners loses customers and fails), so for-profit intermediaries are not inherently bad.Tina Rosenberg on the Kidney Market in Iran
- Ibuka's first product was a shortwave adapter that attached to the common radios people already owned, which was a fast way to reach customers because the installed base existed and shortwave listening had just been legalized, even though parts had to be bought on the black market.#386: Akio Morita: Founder of Sony
- The exploitative organ-trade model—wealthy tourists meeting brokers in poor countries who mistreat desperate donors and pay them far less than the patient pays—exists in many poor countries but not in Iran, precisely because Iran's regulated official paid system removes the conditions for it.Tina Rosenberg on the Kidney Market in Iran
- Iran's paid kidney donation is a legal, regulated official system rather than a black market, and precisely because legal purchase exists, it pre-empts the under-the-table transactions that lead to abuses.Tina Rosenberg on the Kidney Market in Iran
- The US is losing the war on drugs—evidenced by drugs even being smuggled into prisons via drug-soaked book pages—so policies should be judged by consequences not pure intentions; we should experiment with treating addicts more like patients than criminals while not decriminalizing without treatment, learning from places like Switzerland, since Portland's decriminalization had bad city effects without reducing overdose deaths.353 | Alvin Roth on the Economics of Morally Contested Markets
- The United States has vastly overused economic sanctions as a policy tool, the rest of the world is sick of it, sanctions have failed to change behavior in heavily sanctioned countries (Cuba, Iran, North Korea, Venezuela), and when the US sanctions Russians while the rest of the world trades with them through black markets, it reveals the weaponization of the dollar and US financial system for unpopular political strategies.Ben Rhodes: The Warren and Anita Manshel Lecture in American Foreign Policy