big gods
Powerful, moralizing supernatural agents that monitor and punish behavior and reward in an afterlife, contrasted with the weak, whimsical gods of early societies.
As defined in Joseph Henrich
Other definitions
Moralizing deities found in many religious traditions who are believed to watch individuals even when alone and to care morally about their behavior, thereby deterring cheating and free-riding.
Will MacAskill on Longtermism and What We Owe the Future
Where it comes up · 4
- Joseph Henrich3 claims
- How We Tamed Ourselves and Invented Good and Evil (with Hanno Sauer)1 claim
- Will MacAskill on Longtermism and What We Owe the Future1 claim
- 31. Religious Belief by Robert Sapolsky1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “big gods” →
- Religion functions like a social technology, and the key innovation was 'Big Gods'—moralizing gods who watch you even when alone and care what you do—which reduces free-riding and cheating when widely believed; the post-religious era (the world is only ~16% atheist/agnostic) is so young that resurgent free-riding is a genuine worry.Will MacAskill on Longtermism and What We Owe the Future
- Psychologist Ara Norenzayan found that 99% of human history (based on contemporary hunter-gatherer religions) featured gods indifferent to human behavior, but at a certain point of societal complexity—when populations became large enough for anonymous interaction—'big gods' emerged: moralizing gods monitoring and judging behavior, enabling cooperation in high-density societies.31. Religious Belief by Robert Sapolsky
- Big-god religions allowed the construction of well-functioning secular institutions, but once those secular institutions function well, religion loses its functionality and begins to ebb away; this is why good social safety nets are one of the best predictors of atheism in Europe, while the US remains religious due to weaker safety nets and a free market for religion producing a 'Walmart of religion.'Joseph Henrich
- In experiments across the world, the more people believe in a punishing, monitoring big god (Christian or Islamic), the more cooperative and less willing to cheat they are in games; belief in local gods either has no effect or makes people more pro-their-in-group, and unconsciously priming the big god makes people fairer toward out-group coreligionists while priming the local god strengthens in-group favoritism.Joseph Henrich
- Societies that came to believe in supernatural agents with punishing power, which demand certain behaviors of humans, were able to scale up cooperation in larger groups; this transformation from weak, whimsical gods with no afterlife to powerful moralizing gods over the last few thousand years helped consolidate larger human societies.Joseph Henrich
- Theories of cultural evolution show that early urbanization and empires co-evolved with 'Big Gods'—the shift from many goofy nature gods toward a single omniscient, moralistic deity—because as cities grew to tens of thousands of inhabitants, behavior could no longer be monitored, so an all-seeing God who knows your thoughts and punishes wickedness even after death became a powerful cultural invention for enforcing norms at scale.How We Tamed Ourselves and Invented Good and Evil (with Hanno Sauer)