balance of trade
The difference between a nation's exports and imports; mercantilists prized a positive balance, which Hume argued was not the true source of wealth.
As defined in Dennis Rasmussen on Hume and Smith and The Infidel and the Professor
Other definitions
The difference between a country's exports and imports of goods and services; a deficit means importing more than exporting; often blamed on competitiveness but fundamentally determined by exchange rates.
China Trade Deal Doesn't Change Where We're Headed | Luke Gromen
Where it comes up · 3
- China Trade Deal Doesn't Change Where We're Headed | Luke Gromen6 claims
- The Dollar System Is Ending. Here's What Comes Next.2 claims
- Dennis Rasmussen on Hume and Smith and The Infidel and the Professor1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “balance of trade” →
- The reason China has surpassed the US in competitiveness is not unfair practices but superior investment in robotics and manufacturing automation; China's productivity edge is real and deep, and the US cannot compete without either massive investment in equivalent technology (which is inflationary) or currency devaluation.China Trade Deal Doesn't Change Where We're Headed | Luke Gromen
- In classical mercantilism, silver (not gold, which was too rare) was seen as actual wealth, and countries realized they had to run positive trade balances because in a zero-sum world of warring states, positive trade surpluses provided the metal and money needed to buy weaponry and pay mercenaries for defense.The Dollar System Is Ending. Here's What Comes Next.
- Classical mercantilism in medieval and early modern Europe was based on hoarding silver (not gold, which was too rare) because metal itself was considered the only store of wealth, creating zero-sum competition where running a trade surplus was existential because trade deficits meant money flowed out and the economy collapsed.The Dollar System Is Ending. Here's What Comes Next.
- China is more productive than the US by a significant margin, evidenced by China's massive investment in robotics and automation including factories that operate in darkness with robots, and this productivity gap means currency devaluation is the only lever to balance trade since the US cannot out-produce China without comparable investment.China Trade Deal Doesn't Change Where We're Headed | Luke Gromen
- A sustainable trade deal with China must feature a much weaker US dollar against the yuan, but this outcome is politically unspeakable and therefore being obscured through discussion of 'balance of trade' rather than currency adjustment.China Trade Deal Doesn't Change Where We're Headed | Luke Gromen
- China's true balance of trade is flat when gold is priced correctly; China ran a $900 billion trade surplus last year but imported 1,384 tons of gold; at $22,000 per ounce, the gold imports offset the trade surplus, suggesting gold pricing is the real issue underlying trade imbalances.China Trade Deal Doesn't Change Where We're Headed | Luke Gromen
- Balance of trade is fundamentally a currency issue, not a competitiveness issue—the US is not competitive at 7.2, 5.2, or even 4.2 yuan-per-dollar exchange rates, but might be competitive at 3.2 or lower, making Bessent's focus on 'balance of trade' without discussing currency either disingenuous or an euphemism for dollar devaluation.China Trade Deal Doesn't Change Where We're Headed | Luke Gromen
- Hume argued for free trade decades before the Wealth of Nations, contending that a nation's true wealth is not gold, silver, or a positive balance of trade but a productive citizenry; that politicians' attempts to control economic choices are futile or counterproductive; and that free trade benefits all parties and you cannot get rich by beggaring neighbors—though Smith claimed his own free-trade ideas predated Hume's published essays, and Smith's monumental anti-mercantilist argument in one package proved far more influential than Hume's scattered essays.Dennis Rasmussen on Hume and Smith and The Infidel and the Professor
- China imported 1,384 tons of gold last year (at ~$22,000/oz), which if properly priced means China ran a flat balance of trade. If gold were valued at $22,000/oz today, the dollar would trade significantly lower, revealing the inflation-adjusted deficit reality.China Trade Deal Doesn't Change Where We're Headed | Luke Gromen