antinomy
In Kant's system, a contradiction in which both a thesis and its antithesis can be logically proven, suggesting that the question itself presupposes a false framework; characteristic of metaphysical reasoning about the cosmos
As defined in A History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “antinomy” →
- Because Kant can prove both thesis and antithesis in each cosmological antinomy with equal logical weight, we can prove nothing about the cosmos's infinity versus finiteness, divisibility versus indivisibility, freedom versus determinism, or necessity versus contingency—the contradictions reveal the questions are malformedA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- Antinomy occurs in cosmology when arguments can be given that prove both a thesis and its antithesis—e.g., that the world has a beginning in time AND that it has no beginning, both seemingly proven—which violates the law of excluded middle (a or not-a), the fundamental law of logicA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- The third cosmological antinomy concerns causation and freedom: the thesis claims causality according to natural law is insufficient and freedom must exist, while the antithesis claims only natural causation exists and no freedom—both can be logically provenA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- The first cosmological antinomy concerns whether the world is finite or infinite in time and space: the thesis that it has a beginning in time and is limited in space can be proven, and the antithesis that it is infinite in both respects can also be proven, creating a logical contradictionA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- Kant shows that in the first antinomy, assuming the world has no beginning in time leads logically to the conclusion that an infinite series must have elapsed, but infinite series cannot be completed, so the assumption is false and the world must have a beginningA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- The fourth cosmological antinomy concerns necessity and contingency: the thesis claims an absolutely necessary being must exist, while the antithesis claims no such necessary being exists—both propositions are logically provableA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics
- The second cosmological antinomy concerns divisibility: the thesis claims compound substances consist of simple, indivisible parts, while the antithesis claims no simple parts exist—both propositions can be logically proven, creating a second antinomyA History of Philosophy | 54 Kant on Metaphysics