ad hominem
An argument that attacks the person making a claim rather than engaging the claim itself.
As defined in et_730
Where it comes up · 3
- Masters vs. Slaves | Nietzsche's Genealogy of Morality Explained3 claims
- Larry White on the Clash of Economic Ideas2 claims
- David Deutsch on the Pattern1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “ad hominem” →
- Nietzsche claims that every great philosophy is the personal confession of its author—the moral intentions and psychology of the philosopher determine their metaphysical claims, so ad hominem arguments critiquing the thinker rather than the thought are not only valid but necessary to understand how philosophical systems are formed.Masters vs. Slaves | Nietzsche's Genealogy of Morality Explained
- Even though the Pattern is a real irrationality, it is illegitimate to use it as an argument: replying to a claim like 'Israelis committed genocide' by saying 'you're irrational' or 'you just hate Jews' is an ad hominem that should never be used—especially when lives are at stake—because the attributes of the person making an argument cannot be part of the rebuttal; one must instead argue the specific proposition is false.David Deutsch on the Pattern
- Stepping outside the profession, the persistent faith among economists that they can do better than the price system can be read through rent-seeking eyes: the interventionist position grants economists power, and since power motivates everyone else, it likely motivates economists too—though this is speculation White declines to make in his book.Larry White on the Clash of Economic Ideas
- The speaker's ultimate relationship to Nietzsche is one of gratitude and indebtedness combined with dissatisfaction—Nietzsche taught him the validity of ad hominem analysis, but the speaker has become 'too convinced by Nietzsche to be convinced by the rhetoric of the sick.'Masters vs. Slaves | Nietzsche's Genealogy of Morality Explained
- Nietzsche had a dark side and also a positive yes-saying, value-creating side; he is one of the great geniuses of the 20th century whose insights (validity of ad hominem, resentment in moral systems, asceticism as will-to-power) remain invaluable even when his work has fundamental limitations.Masters vs. Slaves | Nietzsche's Genealogy of Morality Explained
- White's book treats economists with bad ideas as sincere and disinterested people rather than rent-seekers, judging their ideas on their merits—whether they would help the economy be more prosperous—rather than on speculation about private motives.Larry White on the Clash of Economic Ideas