normative

Irrationality Diagnosis Is Not a Valid Argument

Even though the Pattern is a real irrationality, it is illegitimate to use it as an argument: replying to a claim like 'Israelis committed genocide' by saying 'you're irrational' or 'you just hate Jews' is an ad hominem that should never be used—especially when lives are at stake—because the attributes of the person making an argument cannot be part of the rebuttal; one must instead argue the specific proposition is false.

normativepending

Speaker

David Deutsch

Evidence Quote

“when one is making an argument for or against some proposition, one can't use the attributes of the person putting forward the argument as part of your argument. That's not legitimate.”

Source

David Deutsch on the Pattern— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:51 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...