Volcker Rule
A provision of Dodd-Frank intended to separate commercial lending from proprietary trading by banks.
As defined in Rana Foroohar on the Financial Sector and Makers and Takers
Other definitions
A Dodd-Frank provision restricting banks from making certain speculative investments (proprietary trading) with their own accounts.
Daniel Carpenter
Where it comes up · 4
- Rana Foroohar on the Financial Sector and Makers and Takers2 claims
- Daniel Carpenter1 claim
- Luigi Zingales on the Costs and Benefits of the Financial Sector1 claim
- Alan Waxman - Private Credit and the Modern Financial System - [Invest Like the Best, EP.466]1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “Volcker Rule” →
- Most regulatory influence occurs before notice-and-comment begins: studies of the Volcker rule found hundreds of pre-proposal meetings, roughly 90 percent of which were with large bank holding companies (JP Morgan, Goldman, Citi) and their law firms and associations, not smaller regional banks—an early agenda-setting stage the Administrative Procedure Act does not regulate at all.Daniel Carpenter
- An academic tally found that 93% of the public consultation meetings on the Volcker Rule were taken with the largest banks—some with just a few institutions like J.P. Morgan and Jamie Dimon himself—illustrating the cognitive capture whereby regulators and even journalists saw nothing wrong with the regulated parties dominating the room.Rana Foroohar on the Financial Sector and Makers and Takers
- Dodd-Frank's complex, labyrinthine regulation imposed compliance burdens that only the biggest banks can easily absorb (by devoting whole departments to it) while smaller banks cannot, making the banking industry more concentrated, so each remaining bank is more systemically important and more able to demand the next, even bigger bailout—while the legislation never solved the too-big-to-fail problem, which comes down to political will.Rana Foroohar on the Financial Sector and Makers and Takers
- Post-crisis reform was inadequate partly because of bank political power: the Volcker Rule (separating proprietary from non-proprietary trading) is very hard to implement, while a cleaner separation of investment banking from commercial banking was not enacted due to bank lobbying pressure.Luigi Zingales on the Costs and Benefits of the Financial Sector
- Dodd-Frank's Volcker Rule, aimed at principal investing, did not last long, so Basel III carried most of the post-GFC regulatory weight for commercial banks while Dodd-Frank mattered mainly in the short term.Alan Waxman - Private Credit and the Modern Financial System - [Invest Like the Best, EP.466]