Unsocial passions
Smith's category for passions such as hatred, resentment, and indignation that involve conflict and therefore produce divided sympathy in observers, as opposed to social passions like gratitude.
As defined in Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 2--A Discussion of Part I 04/15/2009
Other definitions
Smith's category of passions such as hatred and resentment that involve conflict between people and therefore divide our sympathy, making them uncomfortable to share.
Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 2--A Discussion of Part I 04/15/2009
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 3 of 3Search all claims for “Unsocial passions” →
- Resentment and hatred are 'unsocial passions' that are uncomfortable to sympathize with because they involve conflict and divide our sympathy; Smith is no fan of whining or chronic grousing and favors composure, but he insists these passions must be expressed in dignified, moderated form because suppressing them entirely makes society complacent toward injustice.Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 2--A Discussion of Part I 04/15/2009
- Smith treats the unsocial passions (hatred, resentment, indignation) as always somewhat uncomfortable because they create divided sympathy—we cannot side wholly with the resentful person without becoming partial—so resentment is a 'downer' and even when we know its cause we have to be sympathetic to consider it an attractive response.Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 2--A Discussion of Part I 04/15/2009
- Smith rejects a 'teetotaler' approach to resentment and indignation that would abstain from them entirely; just as a teetotaler throws away moderate responsible drinking because he cannot manage it, those who never express indignation lose an important signal—and if people become too blase about outrages and injustices they grow docile and complacent, a problem Klein sees in academia where the 'positive not normative' norm functions as an injunction not to be outspoken.Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 2--A Discussion of Part I 04/15/2009