Tullock paradox
The puzzle, named for economist Gordon Tullock, that firms spend surprisingly little on lobbying given the enormous value governments can transfer to them.
As defined in Luigi Zingales on Capitalism and Crony Capitalism
Where it comes up · 3
- Steve Teles And Brink Lindsey2 claims
- Luigi Zingales1 claim
- Luigi Zingales on Capitalism and Crony Capitalism1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Tullock paradox” →
- The Tullock paradox—that businesses spend surprisingly little on lobbying given the huge sums at stake—is explained partly because politicians value votes not just money, but mainly because the competition is one-sided: the public interest is itself an underfunded, uncoordinated special interest absent from the bargaining table, so winners do not have to pay more.Luigi Zingales on Capitalism and Crony Capitalism
- Gordon Tullock's paradox is that given the trillions of dollars in rents allocated through politics, the collective value of votes should be at least as large, yet votes 'sell cheap' because the public at large cannot coordinate to bid for them while small vested interests organize easily; the gap is partly closed by ideology and Mancur Olson's collective-action logic, and the price has risen over time as parties grow more organized.Luigi Zingales
- The Tullock paradox (that lobbying spending is far lower than the rents government distributes) is explained by institutions absent from Tullock's model: a strong separation of powers locks in the status quo and a limited political agenda restricts what can be debated, so incumbents need not spend heavily to protect existing rents and instead direct effort toward expanding rents they don't yet have.Steve Teles And Brink Lindsey
- The massive distortions visible in the economy, many bearing the fingerprints of insider influence, mean the facts deepen Tullock's paradox rather than resolving it in favor of rent-seeking being unimportant; low lobbying spend coexisting with large distortions makes the puzzle harder, not evidence against rent-seeking.Steve Teles And Brink Lindsey