Trade Adjustment Assistance
A US program intended to redistribute the gains from trade to workers harmed by it; widely viewed as having helped few people.
As defined in Dani Rodrik on Neoliberalism
Other definitions
Government programs providing cash or support to workers displaced by trade, effectively a form of welfare to soften trade's dislocations.
The Economics of Tariffs and Trade (with Doug Irwin)
Where it comes up · 6
- Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/20104 claims
- David Autor on Trade, China, and U.S. Labor Markets1 claim
- Dani Rodrik on Neoliberalism1 claim
- Kimberly Clausing on Open and the Progressive Case for Free Trade1 claim
- Michael Munger on Industrial Policy1 claim
- The Economics of Tariffs and Trade (with Doug Irwin)1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “Trade Adjustment Assistance” →
- Displaced workers often reject welfare checks because what they really want is the dignity of earning a living and supporting their family; protecting their job via import bans is still a hidden handout (taxing fellow citizens by forcing them to buy domestically) but feels like earned work, which is why softening, delaying, or retraining—rather than just cash transfers—may better address dislocation.The Economics of Tariffs and Trade (with Doug Irwin)
- Compensation for trade-displaced workers works well only when it is baked into the original social contract rather than offered as separate assistance; this is why US Trade Adjustment Assistance failed while Europe's generous, source-neutral social welfare state succeeded—because European workers have recourse to a strong safety net regardless of why they lost their job, which is why trade with China or North Africa is not a politically salient issue there.Dani Rodrik on Neoliberalism
- Much of the adjustment to trade shocks flowed onto benefit programs not designed as labor-market programs: while Unemployment Insurance and Trade Adjustment Assistance responded proportionally, the much larger transfers were Disability payments, early retirements, Medicare, Medicaid, TANF, and SNAP—programs that shield against income shocks but lack the incentive properties to return people to work, with Disability being effectively the opposite of employment.David Autor on Trade, China, and U.S. Labor Markets
- Redistributive tools are too blunt to compensate specific losers from policies such as trade liberalization, because Earned Income Tax Credit or training benefits reach many workers beyond those harmed, and side payments are hard to target in public policy.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- Workers who lose jobs through Schumpeterian creative destruction suffer through no fault of their own, which is genuinely unfair, and programs like Trade Adjustment Assistance and unemployment insurance are themselves part of industrial policy designed to reduce the cost of participating in a capitalist system.Michael Munger on Industrial Policy
- Frank's workers in the trade example would be worse off in the short run, possibly for 10 to 20 years or their whole lives, but their children and grandchildren would likely be better off, which is what has generally happened in the US over the last 250 years.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- Trade Adjustment Assistance has not really helped many people, and side payments to pinpoint individuals who lose from trade are very difficult to administer in public policy.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010
- A program of wage insurance could ease worker transitions by having the government subsidize, for a limited time, half the difference when a worker moves from a high-wage job (e.g., $50,000 manufacturing) to a lower-wage one; a small version already exists via Trade Adjustment Assistance for certain workers, but Clausing is indifferent between scaling this and simply expanding the EITC, which would have similar effects more simply.Kimberly Clausing on Open and the Progressive Case for Free Trade
- Trade Adjustment Assistance has not really helped very many people, and compensation for workers harmed by trade is practically difficult in public policy, so trade has not been made win-win for everyone.Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/2010