Soviet (workers' council)
A council of workers' (and later soldiers' and peasants') deputies; the Russian word 'soviet' means council, and these bodies were used as the nominal basis of revolutionary authority.
As defined in Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010
Where it comes up · 1
- Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/201010 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “Soviet (workers' council)” →
- Trotsky believed advanced industrial Germany, not backward Russia or Ukraine, was the country most 'ripe for revolution', but he assumed a German revolution would still require Soviet Red Army intervention because the German middle classes were more determined to resist and the German army less demoralized than Russia's had been in 1917 — which would trigger another European war involving Britain, France and possibly America.Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010
- State terror — dealing with political or economic opponents outside the law using the most brutal repression — was a feature of Soviet rule from its very first year, not a later Stalinist development; Trotsky as much as Stalin supplied the orders and the intellectual rationale, with Trotsky writing a book, 'Terrorism and Communism', arguing terror was an effective way to start a revolutionary dictatorship and quicken the revolutionary schedule.Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010
- The 1917-1924 Soviet system had no blueprint: the world's first one-party state was improvised, with a chaotic, disorganized party that, faced with running an economy and politics across one-sixth of the earth's surface amid revolting peasants and striking workers, had to fall back on its pre-revolutionary doctrines of centralism, discipline and hierarchy to regularize control over the early 1920s.Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010
- The conditions imposed by the Communist International — requiring European and North American socialist splinter groups to form disciplined, centralized communist parties subordinate to Moscow — transformed these parties into instruments Trotsky believed could be used to accelerate revolutionary transformation, leading him to urge the Soviet leadership to take risks and make revolutions.Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010
- The Trotsky-Stalin conflict was not merely personal but a genuine policy dispute: Trotsky wanted to prioritize European socialist revolution and take risks with Soviet security to achieve it, while Stalin wanted to settle the country by pursuing Lenin's New Economic Policy (allowing limited private trade and peasant commerce) to buy a breathing space; Trotsky lost by 1927 partly because he massively underestimated Stalin as a 'pokey little pockmarked Georgian'.Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010
- Trotsky's reputation as a romantic figure (likened to Garibaldi or Bolívar) rests on his role inspiring the Red Army in the Civil War and the fact that he did not personally sign many death warrants (Dzerzhinsky ran the Cheka), but this overlooks his role as one of the architects of one of the most gruesome state-terror dictatorships of the 20th century, justified by his conviction that violent struggle between proletariat and middle classes was inevitable, so one should strike first and big.Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010
- Trotsky never recognized his own responsibility: even after Stalin's far more ruthless dictatorship killed millions, and even after Trotsky himself was assassinated in 1940, he never asked whether he had helped create the conditions for that scale of terror, and never saw the connection between his own extrajudicial murder and the methods he had condoned in 1917-1919.Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010
- Trotsky and Lenin engineered the October 1917 seizure by using the restored workers' Soviets as a blind behind which they put the Bolshevik party in power, exploiting the fact that Kerensky's moderate-socialist provisional government lacked the garrison support to resist.Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010
- Trotsky's terrifying combination was a genuine, quasi-religious idealism about the malleability of human nature — believing communist revolution would liberate talents and produce hundreds of Darwins, thousands of Aristotles, millions of Shakespeares — held by a man with blood on his hands, illustrating how some of the bloodiest killers in Soviet history wrote poetry.Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010
- Stalin notably did not brag about ordering Trotsky's assassination and the Soviet Union denied it, even as the assassin Ramón Mercader maintained for years in Mexican prison that he was merely a disillusioned Trotskyist; the truth that Stalin ordered it was nonetheless universally inferred at the time and Mercader was later spirited to the USSR and feted as a hero.Robert Service on Trotsky 07/26/2010