Shia
The second-largest branch of Islam; the regime in Iran is Shia, in contrast to Sunni Hamas
As defined in 340 - The Bright Line Between Good And Evil
Where it comes up · 7
- The Infernal Logic of Jihad: A Conversation with Graeme Wood (Episode #339)2 claims
- 340 - The Bright Line Between Good And Evil1 claim
- 47 - The Frontiers Of Political Correctness1 claim
- 339 - The Infernal Logic Of Jihad1 claim
- 278 - The Man Who Will Be King1 claim
- Lior Susan - Leave the World Better than You Found It - [Invest Like the Best, EP.353]1 claim
- Peter Zeihan Interview - Hamas, Gaza, Israel and the Possibility of Outside Intervention - Oct 20231 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “Shia” →
- Hamas, unlike ISIS, spent years actually governing and managing basic services in Gaza, which required flexibility and pragmatism, leading to a messier, less ideologically pure organization that would accept nationalists and Shia allies like Iran and Hezbollah, while maintaining a relatively clear charter describing a future worldwide Muslim government.The Infernal Logic of Jihad: A Conversation with Graeme Wood (Episode #339)
- ISIS would view Hamas with extreme hostility (viewing them as apostates requiring death) because Hamas practices theological compromise, engages in nationalism, and collaborates with Shia actors like Iran and Hezbollah, violating ISIS's doctrine of uncompromising Islamic purity.The Infernal Logic of Jihad: A Conversation with Graeme Wood (Episode #339)
- Iran has no tools to affect the Gaza situation; Hamas was always considered a disposable asset by Iran; Hezbollah is a more valuable long-term partner for Iran due to Shia religious affiliation while Hamas is Sunni and considered apostates worthy of destruction.Peter Zeihan Interview - Hamas, Gaza, Israel and the Possibility of Outside Intervention - Oct 2023
- Iran is itself an avowedly jihadist state, but of a Shia variety, and has been an enemy of Sunni Saudi Arabia since Iran's conversion into a jihadist state in the late 1970s, which is why describing MBS as anti-jihadist and anti-Iran is broadly true with important caveats.278 - The Man Who Will Be King
- Jihadists are not a unified front — there is a deep Sunni-Shia schism and internecine divisions even among jihadists of the same faith (the Afghan and Pakistani Taliban don't get along), which is a good thing that smart people with language skills should exploit by sowing hatred and confusion among jihadist groups.340 - The Bright Line Between Good And Evil
- Despite the fragmentation of the jihadist landscape — the Shia-Sunni split, infighting among Sunni groups, and ISIS excommunicating Hamas as apostates for playing the nationalist game and allying with Shia Iran — jihadists are ultimately united in their hatred of secular pluralistic Western values and their aspiration to spread Islam to the ends of the earth.339 - The Infernal Logic Of Jihad
- Despite being a dangerous buffoon, Donald Trump strikes a more honest note than mainstream politicians by acknowledging there is a specific problem with Islam, even though his understanding is only superficial—he doesn't grasp the Sunni/Shia distinction or the geography of the Middle East.47 - The Frontiers Of Political Correctness
- Lior claims that all the radical extremists are Shia while the Persian people are Sunni and treated as second-class citizens by Iran, a sectarian framing that misstates the actual sectarian composition of the groups he names.Lior Susan - Leave the World Better than You Found It - [Invest Like the Best, EP.353]